lgd-skill-review

Use when reviewing, auditing or scoring any AI skill package, or when a skill was rejected and you need to know why. A dual-ruler reviewer: reports a structure score (100) and a semantics score (120) as two orthogonal verdicts instead of merging them, and flags the case when the two disagree by 20 points or more. Structure asks whether the package can be used at all (tests, declared-vs-implemented consistency, reproducibility, hygiene, discovery, licensing); semantics asks whether it is worth using (knowledge delta, procedures, anti-patterns with reasons, specification, progressive disclosure, freedom calibration, pattern fit, usability). Every finding carries a stable ID and is traceable to a specific file. Accepts evidence-based appeals: the appellant supplies a path and a check, the engine opens it and rules OVERTURNED / UPHELD, and records the ruling in appeal_log.json. Appeals never silently change a score - they turn a deduction into a verifiable dispute.