social-security-claiming-timer
Use when deciding WHEN to claim Social Security (62 vs Full Retirement Age vs 70), modeling break-even ages, early-claim reductions, delayed retirement credits, the earnings test before FRA, or longevity-quartile strategy — computes month-accurate benefit factors by birth year, cumulative-benefit crossover ages for any pair of claiming ages, and names which strategy wins at the 25th/50th/75th percentile lifespan, instead of the folklore "take it early to be safe" or "always delay" one-size answers.
Social Security Claiming Timer
Overview
The single biggest irreversible retirement decision most Americans make — claiming age — is made with folklore. "Take it at 62 because you might die" and "wait to 70 because you get 24% more" are both half-truths: the honest answer is a break-even age, and it is computable from three inputs: birth year, Primary Insurance Amount (PIA, the benefit at Full Retirement Age from your ssa.gov statement), and your longevity outlook.
This tool does the month-accurate arithmetic the SSA uses — early reductions of 5/9 of 1% per month for the first 36 months and 5/12 of 1% beyond, delayed retirement credits of 2/3 of 1% per month after FRA, the FRA table by birth year (66 → 67 drift) — then runs the cumulative-benefit crossover for any pair of claiming ages and reads the verdict against approximate longevity quartiles. It also prices the earnings test trap (working at 63 while claiming can withhold checks — though withheld money is recalc'd, not lost) and carries the survivor-benefit rule of thumb: the higher earner's delay protects the surviving spouse.
When to Use
- Deciding between claiming at 62, FRA, 70, or anywhere between (yes, claiming at 64 is legal and common)
- "Will waiting to 70 pay off?" — get the exact break-even age, not vibes
- Still working past 62 and claiming — earnings-test withholding math
- Couple coordinating: who claims when (higher earner delays → survivor benefit logic)
- Checking a financial advisor's claiming chart for arithmetic errors (they circulate)
Don't use for: disability (SSDI — different rules), computing PIA from earnings history (take it from the ssa.gov statement), or non-US pensions. Not tax advice: up to 85% of benefits can be taxable — see references.
Quick Start
# Full claiming table 62→70 for someone born 1962 with $2,400/mo PIA
python3 scripts/ss_claim_optimizer.py plan --birth-year 1962 --pia 2400
# The classic question: 62 vs 70 — where's the crossover?
python3 scripts/ss_claim_optimizer.py plan --birth-year 1962 --pia 2400 \
--compare 62 70 --longevity female
# Working at 63 with a $55,000 salary while claiming
python3 scripts/ss_claim_optimizer.py earnings-check --birth-year 1962 --pia 2400 \
--claim-age 63 --salary 55000
python3 scripts/ss_claim_optimizer.py --demo # worked example, no arguments needed
The Engine (what the math actually is)
- FRA lookup by birth year: 1943–1954 → 66y 0m; 1955–1959 → 66y +2m/yr; 1960+ → 67y 0m.
- Benefit factor for claiming age A given FRA:
- Early (A < FRA): first 36 early months × 5/9 of 1% each; further months × 5/12 of 1%. Born 1960+ claiming at 62 = 60 early months = exactly 70% of PIA.
- Delayed (A > FRA): 2/3 of 1% per month = 8%/yr, capped at 70. FRA 67 → 124% at 70; FRA 66 → 132%.
- Cumulative crossover: sum monthly checks from each claiming date forward; find the age where strategy B overtakes strategy A. Nominal and discount-adjusted (
--discount, default 0 — benefits are COLA-indexed, so real terms is the honest default). - Longevity read-out: break-even vs approximate quartiles (62-year-old female ≈ P25 81 / P50 86 / P75 91; male ≈ 78/83/88 — SSA-period-based approximations, stated as such). If break-even sits below P25, delaying is a bet against a long life; above P50, claiming early loses money in the median case.
- Earnings test (2026 limits, indexed): under FRA year $1 withheld per $2 over $23,400; FRA year $1 per $3 over $62,160 (months before FRA only); no test after FRA. Withheld checks are recalculated into your benefit at FRA (ARF) — the script says so, because "you lose it" is the most common myth it kills.
Verdicts
DELAY WINS AT P50— break-even below median lifespanEARLY WINS AT P50— crossover beyond median life expectancyTOO CLOSE TO CALL— break-even within ~2 yr of the relevant quartileEARNINGS TEST BITES— withholding math materially changes year-1 cash
Common Pitfalls
- Comparing monthly checks instead of lifetime cash. 124% vs 70% of PIA is noise; the crossover age is the signal.
- Ignoring the FRA birth-year drift. Advice written for a 1950-born (FRA 66, 25% cut at 62) is wrong for a 1962-born (30% cut). The script pins FRA from birth year.
- Treating earnings-test withholding as theft. It is a delayed, interest-free hold; your benefit is re-adjusted upward at FRA.
- Couple-level blindness. For a married couple, the higher earner's age-70 claim often survives as the survivor benefit — worth up to decades of the larger check for the widow(er). Single-decision framing misses this (see references).
- Forgetting break-even is a distribution question, not an expected-value question. Read the verdict at your health/longevity quartile, not the population median.
Verification Checklist
- FRA printed matches SSA's table for the birth year
- Factor at 62 and 70 spot-checked (1960+ born: 0.700 / 1.240)
- Crossover age from
comparematches the cumulative table's crossing row - Discount left at 0 unless the user insists on a personal time preference
Example
Born 1962, PIA $2,400. Claim 62 → $1,680/mo from age 62.0; claim 70 → $2,976/mo from 70.0. Cumulative crossover lands ≈ age 80–81 (standard result). At male P50 (≈83) delaying wins by ~$40k nominal; at male P25 (≈78) early wins. The tool prints exactly this, with the honest "if your health outlook is below-median, the early claim is rational" line most calculators refuse to give.
- Downloads
- Security audit
- Pass
- Last updated
- 1w ago
- Current version
- v1.0.0
- License
- MIT-0
