Open-Enrollment Optimizer
Use during fall benefits/open-enrollment window (or Medicare Oct 15-Dec 7) to choose health plans, FSA/HSA elections, and insurance elections. Models true annual cost of each plan across healthy/typical/high-use scenarios, computes FSA use-it-or-lose-it risk and optimal election, and prices HSA vs FSA vs taxable over a horizon.
Open-Enrollment Optimizer — Benefits Elections Without the Guesswork
Overview
Open enrollment is a 2–6 week annual window where people lock in five-figures-worth of decisions (premiums, deductibles, tax-advantaged accounts, life insurance multiples) from a 40-page PDF, under deadline pressure, with no do-over until next year. The dominant mistake is premium-shopping: picking the lowest-premium plan while ignoring that one plan's deductible changes total annual cost by thousands for the same care. The second mistake is parking the same FSA number every year — or forfeiting it.
This skill computes true annual cost of candidate plans across three utilization scenarios (healthy year / typical year / bad-luck year), prices FSA elections against realistic spending with rollover rules, and shows the multi-year tax advantage of HSA-eligibility when choosing a high-deductible plan. Verdicts name the winner per scenario and the robust all-round pick.
When to Use
- User mentions open enrollment, benefits election, "which health plan should I pick", FSA/HSA decision, or comparing employer plan tiers (bronze/silver/gold, PPO vs HDHP)
- Medicare Part D / Advantage annual election (Oct 15 – Dec 7): plan comparison method applies; drug-formulary specifics belong to the plan finder, but the cost math is here
- Life events outside the window (marriage, birth, job loss → special enrollment) — same math
- Don't use for: claims/billing disputes, finding specific in-network doctors (network check is a manual gate, see Workflow step 3), or tax filing itself
Core Knowledge
1. True annual cost (the only number that matters)
TAC(scenario) = 12 × premium + min(max(claims, deductible) × coinsurance + claims_below_ded,
claims) ...capped at out-of-pocket max + premiums
Precisely, per scenario with expected claims C:
- If
C ≤ deductible: you payC(all deductible-eligible) - If
C > deductible: you paydeductible + (C − deductible) × coinsurance - Capped at
out-of-pocket max(in-network) - Always add
12 × monthly premium - Add copays separately if the plan is copay-based (script supports both)
A $0-deductible plan at $180/mo more can be cheaper than the HDHP for a pregnancy year — and $3,000 more expensive for a healthy year. The scenarios make this visible instead of vibed.
2. FSA election math
- Use-it-or-lose-it with a grace-period OR carryover election (IRS allows ~$660+ carryover,
inflation-indexed —
--fsauses the current figure; verify annually). - Optimal election = min(expected qualifying spend, risk-adjusted for the chance you leave
spending unspent). The script prices forfeiture:
election × P(underspend)vs tax saved on every used dollar (marginal rate + FICA ≈ 30–40% for most). - Dependent-care FSA has its own cap ($5,000) and different mechanics — separate line.
3. HSA triple advantage
Contributions dodge income tax, grow tax-free, and come out tax-free for medical spend — the only
triple-tax-advantaged account in US law. Paying medical costs out-of-pocket and saving receipts
lets the HSA act as a stealth retirement account. --hsa computes the N-year difference vs
taxable investing at the same gross contribution.
4. Elections people forget cost real money
- Re-electing the same plan when the plan's premium/deductible/network changed (they do change)
- Life insurance through work beyond 1–2× salary: portability is poor; buy term privately for the gap, but 1× free coverage is always take it
- Not naming beneficiaries (retirement, life) — defaults are wrong after marriage/divorce
- Skipping the HSA employer seed ($500–$1,500/yr free money on HDHP)
- SDP/HCFSA for FEHB folks, vision/dental only if you have planned procedures
Workflow
- Gather for each candidate plan: monthly premium (all tiers: employee / +spouse / +family), deductible, coinsurance %, out-of-pocket max, copays, HSA-eligibility + employer seed.
- Estimate scenarios (script defaults are sane; adjust to the user):
- healthy: ~$500 claims (a physical + a couple sick visits)
- typical: ~$3,000 (a managed condition, one procedure, meds)
- bad-luck: ~$15,000+ (surgery, ER, imaging — this tests the OOP max)
- Gate manually BEFORE math: is your doctor/medication in-network/formulary? A cheap plan that drops your specialist has TAC = ∞. No script can do this — ask the user.
- Run:
bash python3 scripts/enrollment_optimizer.py --demo python3 scripts/enrollment_optimizer.py --plans plans.json python3 scripts/enrollment_optimizer.py --fsa 1400 --spend 1200 --taxrate 32 python3 scripts/enrollment_optimizer.py --hsa 4300 8 25 - Read verdicts: per-scenario winner, robust winner, the premium-vs-deductible crossover claims amount ("below $X/yr in claims, Plan A wins; above, Plan B").
- FSA/HSA: election + expected forfeiture vs tax saved; HDHP premium savings + seed added to the HSA column before declaring an HDHP winner.
- Lock the calendar: elections deadline, FSA claims deadline + grace period dates.
Verdicts
| Output | Meaning |
|---|---|
WINS: <plan> (<$X TAC) | lowest true annual cost for that scenario |
| ROBUST PICK | wins or near-ties across all three scenarios |
| CROSSOVER | claims $/yr where the ranking flips — the honest answer to "which is cheaper" |
| FORFEIT RISK | FSA dollars at risk if spending comes in low |
Common Pitfalls
- Premium-shopping. Lowest premium ≠ lowest cost; the deductible and coinsurance dominate any year you actually use care. Always compare TAC at your scenario, not the paycheck delta.
- Assuming last year's plan is unchanged. Networks shrink silently; premiums rise 5–10%. Re-verify doctor + drug every year even if you re-elect.
- FSA parking / round numbers. Electing "what I did last year" or a round $2,000 forfeits real dollars. Elect expected spend minus carryover headroom.
- Ignoring the OOP max in the bad-luck scenario. A low premium/high-max plan can expose you to $2–4k more in a surgery year. The bad-luck scenario exists to surface exactly this.
- HSA-eligible + not funding the HSA. HDHP without HSA funding is just a high deductible.
- Missing the deadline. Nov/Dec deadlines are hard; missing them locks defaults (often the most expensive option or no FSA at all).
Verification Checklist
- All candidate plans entered with premium/deductible/coinsurance/OOP-max
- TAC computed for healthy / typical / bad-luck scenarios for every plan
- Manual gate done: doctors in-network, meds on formulary
- Crossover claims number stated
- FSA election justified vs expected spend + forfeiture risk priced
- HDHP candidates include employer seed + premium savings in the comparison
- Deadlines (election + FSA claims + grace) written down
One-Shot Recipe: PPO vs HDHP for a family
PPO $520/mo, $1,500 ded, 20% coins, $6k OOP max vs HDHP $360/mo, $3,000 ded, 20% coins, $8k OOP max, employer seeds $1,000 to HSA. Healthy year: HDHP wins by ~$2,400 (premiums + seed). Typical year ($6k claims): PPO ≈ $6,240 + $500 = total ~$8,900; HDHP ≈ $3,000 + $600 = $3,600 capped math + premiums − seed ≈ $7,920 — HDHP still wins. Bad-luck ($20k claims): PPO caps at $6,000 + $6,240 ≈ $12,240; HDHP caps at $8,000 + $4,320 − $1,000 ≈ $11,320 — closer. Verdict: HDHP robust, fund the HSA with the premium difference, copays for meds confirmed on formulary.
- Downloads
- Security audit
- Pass
- Last updated
- 2w ago
- Current version
- v1.0.0
- License
- MIT-0
