Use when reviewing a new-car purchase quote, lease deal, or 'out-the-door' price. Audits OTD line items (doc fees vs state caps, taxed rebates, dealer add-on padding), decodes lease money factor into real APR, and compares financing against a pre-approved loan.
A new-car "out-the-door" price is a stack of legitimate charges, state-capped fees, and pure dealer
padding. Sales tax on rebates varies by state; documentation fees range from a $75 cap in some
states to uncapped $500+ elsewhere; add-ons like "VIN etching" ($1495 for a $0 product) ride the
final worksheet because buyers are exhausted by then. Leases hide the real interest rate behind a
"money factor" that almost nobody converts to APR.
This skill takes a quote (paste of line items, or structured input) and returns an itemized audit:
every line classified FAIR / CAPPED-BY-LAW / PADDED / REFUSE, total padding found, corrected
OTD, lease money-factor → APR decode, and financing comparison vs a pre-approved rate.
When to Use
User shares a new-car purchase worksheet, OTD quote, or "drive-off" lease numbers
Comparing lease vs buy, or dealer financing vs bank pre-approval
A deal includes mandatory add-ons ("pro pack", ceramic coating, paint protection)
Verifying that a quoted monthly payment actually matches the stated price and APR
Don't use for: used-car condition/mileage audits (that's inspection territory), trade-in valuation
alone, or rideshare/rental topics
Core Knowledge
1. Anatomy of an honest OTD
text
OTD = negotiated price (or capitalized cost on a lease)
- rebates / incentives / trade credit
+ sales tax (on the CORRECT base — see §2)
+ title & registration (state schedule — fair, non-negotiable)
+ doc/documentary fee (state-capped in many states — see references)
+ ANY gov-mandated fees (tire fee, battery fee, emissions — small, legit)
+ NOTHING ELSE
Anything past that — "dealer services", "market adjustment", "pro pack", "surface protection",
"VIN etch", "nitrogen fill" — is padding. Fair value of every classic add-on is in
references/addon-catalog.md; nearly all are worth $0–$50, not the $295–$1995 charged.
2. Sales tax on rebates — state dependent
Most states tax price AFTER manufacturer rebates (rebate reduces taxable base).
Tax-on-rebate states (rebate is taxable income to you): TX, and several others — see the
table in references/state-rules.md. In tax-on-rebate states a $3000 rebate saves you less than
$3000 + tax math suggests; the worksheet must show tax computed on the pre-rebate price.
Trade-in credit reduces taxable base in most states, but NOT in CA, DC, HI, MI, VA and a few
others (tax paid on full price even with a trade).
Quote MF × 2400 and compare to stated/known APR. Dealer-marked-up MFs (buy-rate + 0.0002–0.0004)
add $9–$18/month per $10k of cap cost — pure profit.
Drive-off must be decomposed: 1st payment + cap reduction + acquisition fee + DMV. A big "down"
on a lease (cap cost reduction) is uninsured cash — if the car is totaled, you don't get it back.
Missing disclosures: residual $, MF, acquisition fee, disposition fee, mileage cap, per-mile
overage rate. Any refusal to show the MF is a walk-away.
4. Financing sanity
Compute payment from principal/rate/term (amortized). If dealer payment > formula payment, the gap
is markup (rate bump) or a hidden fee. Dealer "buy rate" markup of 1–2% APR is standard practice
unless the lender caps it.
Workflow
Collect the quote — every line item with $ amounts, state, and whether cash/finance/lease.
Get the itemized worksheet, never just a monthly payment or "OTD: $41,995".
Run the audit:bash
python3 scripts/otd_decoder.py --demo # see the shape
python3 scripts/otd_decoder.py --quote quote.json # real audit
(build quote.json from scripts/quote.example.json.)
Read the verdict table: total padding, corrected OTD, per-line REFUSE list.
Lease? Feed MF/term/residual/cap — get effective APR + payment verification + the markup
vs a 0.00040-bump estimate.
Financing? Feed price minus rebates, rate offers — get payment comparison and total interest.
Counter using the scripts in references/negotiation-playbook.md: email-only OTD requests,
"out-the-door or nothing" language, the add-on refuse list wording.
Verdicts the script returns
Verdict
Meaning
FAIR
Market-real (e.g., a genuine discount off MSRP)
STATE-CAPPED
Legal fee at/below cap (verify against references)
OVER-CAP
Doc fee above your state cap — demand reduction to cap
PADDED
Real product, cartoon price — counter at fair value
Negotiating monthly payment instead of OTD. Payment games hide term/rate/APR. Always
negotiate the single OTD number; financing is a separate conversation.
Forgetting tax-on-rebate states. In TX-class states, a $3,000 rebate ≈ $3,000 minus your
tax rate applied to that $3,000 back — rebates are less valuable than sticker math suggests.
Cap-cost reduction on a lease. Big drive-off cash is uninsured. Keep drive-off to first
payment + fees; roll the rest into the cap cost.
Trusting the "money factor is not negotiable" line. MF is rate markup-able AND negotiable —
especially with manufacturer subvented lease programs (check the subvention MF before markup).
Add-ons framed as "already installed." Anything pre-installed can be refused or charged at
fair value; "we can't remove it" → "then I'm not paying for it" (see playbook).
Doc fee "we can't change it." True in cap states at the cap — but the discount can absorb it
elsewhere. In uncapped states it's negotiable like any other line.
Verification Checklist
Every quote line classified with a verdict and a reason
Corrected OTD computed (quote total − REFUSE − PADDED-overflow)
Lease: MF × 2400 stated as effective APR, payment re-derived from formula, matches quote ±$2
Financing: payment from amortization formula matches quoted payment ±$1
State column checked: doc-fee cap, rebate taxation, trade-in taxation
User leaves with: corrected OTD + refuse list + one counter-email draft
One-Shot Recipe: "they quoted $2,495 of add-ons"
Quote shows: Surface protection $495, VIN etch $1,495, all-weather mats $495, nitrogen $210.
Audit → REFUSE surface protection (dealer's own cost ≈ a $15 bottle), REFUSE VIN etch (insurance
companies give the discount without it; etch kits cost ~$20), PADDED mats (counter $150–200 — real
product), REFUSE nitrogen (air is 78% N₂; zero measurable benefit for street cars).
Total corrected: −$2,390. Mats stay at $180: corrected OTD ≈ quote − $2,100.