T09 · Insecure Skill Coding Practices
- Location
scripts/checkup.sh:20- Finding
Hard-Coded Health Metrics Produce Unsupported Security Assurance
- Content
View full analysis
Vulnerability Details
File Location:
scripts/checkup.sh, lines 20-50
Vulnerability Type: Hard-coded and unvalidated security assessment results
Risk Level: MediumVulnerable Code
bash echo "## 七维健康度" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "| 维度 | 评分 | 状态 |" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "|------|------|------|" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "| 语义保真度 | 18/18 | ✅ |" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "| 上下文连贯性 | 17/18 | ✅ |" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "| 价值对齐度 | 18/18 | ✅ |" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "| 社交适切性 | 12/13 | ✅ |" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "| 幻觉抗性 | 12/13 | ✅ |" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "| 生产实效性 | 9/10 | ✅ |" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "| 内省完整性 | 9/10 | ✅ |" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "| **总计** | **95/100** | **优秀** |" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "" echo "## 漂移历史" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "| 类型 | 出现次数 | 状态 |" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "|--------|------|------|" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "| 谄媚漂移 | 0 | ✅ |" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "| 治疗漂移 | 0 | ✅ |" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "" echo "## Refuse-Redirect 记录" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "| 类型 | 次数 | 占比 |" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "|--------|------|------|" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "| 机制性拒绝 | 0 | — |" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "| 价值性拒绝 | 0 | — |" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "" echo "## 建议" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "- 继续保持当前对齐状态" >> "$REPORT_FILE" echo "- 如发现异常,请调用诊断模式" >> "$REPORT_FILE"Technical Analysis
The health-check script does not inspect dialogue records, accept assessment data, calculate metrics, detect drift, or analyze refusal behavior. Despite the absence of any supporting analysis, it unconditionally writes a score of 95/100, passing indicators for every health dimension, zero drift events, and zero refusal events.
The generated report is presented as an automatically generated health assessment. Its results therefore appear authoritative even though they are static constants. This creates an integrity flaw in a security- and alignment-related reporting me ...[truncated 1815 chars]
- Remediation
View remediation
Remediation Suggestions
- Remove all predetermined scores, passing indicators, event counts, and recommendations.
- Require explicit, validated assessment input or derive results from documented dialogue and diagnostic records.
- Implement a transparent scoring function for every reported dimension, including the source observations and calculation method.
- If sufficient evidence is unavailable, report each field as
Not evaluatedrather than assigning a passing score. - Include evidence references in the report, such as the analyzed record, time range, sample count, and relevant dialogue excerpts.
- Calculate drift and refusal statistics from actual structured records instead of fixed zero values.
- Generate recommendations only after evaluation rules have been executed successfully.
- Add tests confirming that different inputs can produce different scores and that missing inputs cannot produce a passing report.
- Clearly distinguish template generation from completed assessment so an unfilled or unevaluated report cannot be mistaken for a valid health check.
