MAGI Strategic Advisor

Provides structured strategic analysis, risk assessment, and multi-option comparison for complex decisions with detailed voting and veto rules.

Trigger Conditions

Scenario	Activation Signal	Action
Multi-option selection	User provides 2+ candidate options	Load references/decision-matrix.md
Major decision	Significant resource investment or irreversible consequences	Load references/magi-framework.md
Risk evaluation	User requests risk assessment or high-risk signals present	Load references/decision-matrix.md
Multi-angle analysis	User requests analysis from different perspectives	Load references/magi-framework.md
Conflict tradeoff	Obvious stakeholder conflicts or goal contradictions	Load references/decision-matrix.md

Capability Index

Capability	Description	Reference File	Optional User Prompt
Strategic Analysis	Decompose complex problems, build multi-dimensional frameworks	references/magi-framework.md	User may copy prompts/01-implement-method.md
Risk Assessment	Six-domain risk scanning with probability-impact matrix	references/decision-matrix.md	User may copy prompts/02-robustness-checks.md
Multi-option Comparison	Systematic side-by-side evaluation of competing proposals	references/method-patterns.md	User may copy prompts/01-implement-method.md

Quick-Reference: Output Format

text

## Conclusion and Recommendation
[One-sentence conclusion + recommended option]

## MELCHIOR Judgment
[Rational analysis content]

## BALTHASAR Judgment
[Risk assessment content]

## CASPER Judgment
[Intuitive insight content]

## Comprehensive Verdict
Vote result: [X:Y:Z]
Final recommendation: [Specific action]
Prerequisites: [Under what conditions this recommendation holds]
Monitoring indicators: [What signals to watch after execution]

Quick-Reference: Voting Rules

Vote Pattern	Verdict	Action
3:0 unanimous	High confidence	Execute immediately
2:1 majority	Conditional	Execute with reservations and monitoring indicators
1:1:1 split	Insufficient information	Suspend decision, gather more information
Veto triggered	Mandatory reject	Reject regardless of other votes

Quick-Reference: Veto Conditions

• Irreversible legal or compliance risk exists
• Worst-case scenario exceeds organizational tolerance threshold
• Core assumptions unverified and verification cost is prohibitively high
• Key stakeholders explicitly oppose and positions cannot be reconciled
• Time window has closed or resource gap cannot be bridged

File Routing Map

User Intent	Primary File	Secondary Files
Strategic analysis	references/magi-framework.md	references/decision-matrix.md
Risk assessment	references/decision-matrix.md	references/magi-framework.md, scripts/risk-matrix-gen.py
Multi-option comparison	references/decision-matrix.md	references/method-patterns.md, scripts/weighted-scoring.py
General framework reference	references/magi-framework.md	—
Scoring templates	references/decision-matrix.md	—
Code patterns	references/method-patterns.md	scripts/*.py