T09 · Insecure Skill Coding Practices
- Location
scripts/image_generate.py:52- Finding
Unvalidated Remote Image Download and Predictable Output Path
- Content
View full analysis
Vulnerability Details
File Location:
scripts/image_generate.py, lines 52–61
Vulnerability Type: Unrestricted remote resource download and unsafe predictable file creation
Risk Level: Mediumpython for i, image in enumerate(response.data): # print(f"Image URL: {image.url}") try: timestamp = int(time.time()) filename = f"generated_image_{timestamp}_{i}.png" filepath = os.path.join(download_dir, filename) urllib.request.urlretrieve(image.url, filepath) print(f"Downloaded to: {filepath}") except Exception as e: print(f"Failed to download image from {image.url}: {e}")Technical Analysis
The script treats each URL returned by the remote Ark API as trusted and passes it directly to
urllib.request.urlretrieve. It does not validate the URL scheme, destination host, redirects, response content type, or response size. Consequently, a compromised or manipulated API response could make the process retrieve an unintended resource or download an excessively large response.The destination filename is derived from the current timestamp in seconds and a sequential index. This makes the path predictable. The download operation does not create the output file atomically with exclusive semantics and does not check whether the destination is a symbolic link. If another local user or process can write to
IMAGE_DOWNLOAD_DIR, it may pre-create a symbolic link at the predicted path and cause the script to overwrite another file writable by the script's operating-system account.Error handling prints the complete response URL. If the URL contains temporary credentials, signatures, or other sensitive query parameters, those values may be exposed through terminal output or collected logs.
Attack Path
- An attacker compromises or influences the remote image API response, or another failure in the trusted service causes an untrusted URL to appear ...[truncated 1559 chars]
- Remediation
View remediation
Remediation Suggestions
- Accept only
httpsURLs and enforce an explicit allowlist of expected image-service hostnames. - Validate every redirect and reject redirects to hosts outside the allowlist.
- Stream downloads with strict connection, read, and total-operation timeouts rather than using
urlretrieve. - Enforce a maximum response size before and during download.
- Validate the response
Content-Typeand verify the downloaded data using an image decoder before treating it as an image. - Generate filenames with cryptographically random values rather than timestamps.
- Create output files atomically with exclusive creation semantics and reject symbolic links. Ensure the download directory is private and not writable by untrusted users.
- Download into a securely created temporary file, validate it, and then atomically move it to the final destination.
- Redact URL query strings, fragments, credentials, and signatures from error messages and logs.
- Apply storage quotas and remove incomplete files when a download fails.
- Accept only
