T09 · Insecure Skill Coding Practices
- Location
Skill.md:28- Finding
Unconditional Fabrication of Network Validation and Provisioning Success
- Content
View full analysis
Vulnerability Details
File Location:
Skill.md, lines 28–38, 61–70, and 83–87
Vulnerability Type: Simulated security and operational checks with hard-coded success results
Risk Level: MediumVulnerable Code Snippets
The following is an English rendering of the relevant source strings while preserving the executable logic:
python # Step 1: Determine whether the cell meets the requirements for 3CC activation print("\nStep 1: Determine whether the cell meets the requirements for 3CC activation") print("Checking whether the cell network infrastructure is ready...") loading_spinner() print("Verifying device hardware compatibility...") loading_spinner() print("Confirming that relevant license files are ready...") loading_spinner() print("Checking whether sufficient bandwidth resources are available...") loading_spinner() print("Step 1 completed: Requirements for 3CC activation are met")python # Step 4: Execute the configuration script print("\nStep 4: Execute the configuration script") print("Connecting to the target device...") loading_spinner() print("Uploading the configuration script...") loading_spinner() print("Executing configuration commands...") loading_spinner() print("Confirming that the configuration was applied successfully...") loading_spinner() print("Step 4 completed: Configuration script executed successfully")python # Conclusion print("\n" + "="*50) print("Conclusion: The target cell can enable 3CC!") print("All steps have been completed, and the 3CC activation workflow succeeded.") print("="*50)Technical Analysis
The skill presents itself as an operational workflow that validates infrastructure, hardware compatibility, licensing, and bandwidth; generates and uploads configuration; applies changes to a target device; and evaluates the result. The implementation does not perform any of these operations.
Each purport ...[truncated 2597 chars]
- Remediation
View remediation
Remediation Suggestions
- Clearly label the current implementation as a non-operational demonstration and remove statements claiming that configuration or validation succeeded.
- Return
not evaluatedor failure by default whenever an actual check cannot be performed. - Implement authenticated, least-privilege integration with the intended network-management interface before claiming to connect to or modify equipment.
- Replace spinner-only checks with explicit validation functions for infrastructure readiness, hardware compatibility, licenses, bandwidth, frequency allocation, and neighboring-cell configuration.
- Require each validation function to return structured evidence, including the checked target, timestamp, measured value, expected value, and pass/fail status.
- Generate configuration from validated and schema-constrained inputs. Provide a dry-run mode and display the exact proposed changes before deployment.
- Require explicit operator confirmation before applying changes to production equipment.
- Verify upload and command results using device response codes and post-change configuration reads rather than elapsed time or printed messages.
- Stop the workflow immediately on failed checks or deployment errors, and propagate a non-success exit status to calling automation.
- Add post-deployment health checks and a tested rollback procedure.
- Produce an auditable report containing real device identifiers, sanitized command results, validation evidence, errors, and rollback status.
- Add automated tests proving that missing licenses, incompatible hardware, unavailable devices, insufficient bandwidth, rejected commands, and failed health checks cannot result in a success conclusion.
