T05 · Unauthorized Access and Privilege Escalation
- Location
SKILL.md:21- Finding
Unnecessary Command-Execution Permission Violates Least Privilege
- Content
View full analysis
Vulnerability Details
File Location:
SKILL.md:21-24
Vulnerability Type: Excessive system-tool permission
Risk Level: MediumVulnerable Code
yaml tools: - read - exec - writeThe command-execution capability is also advertised at
SKILL.md:198, although the project provides no implementation that enforces the claimed sandbox.Technical Analysis
The Skill declares the unrestricted
exectool even though its documented purpose is to add, remove, replace, and organize knowledge notes. That workflow requires controlled file reading and writing but does not establish a legitimate need for arbitrary system-command execution.The package consists only of
SKILL.md. It contains no executable implementation, command allowlist, argument validation, shell-isolation policy, or sandbox configuration. Consequently, the documentation's claim that commands run in a secure sandbox is not enforced by anything in the audited project.If the hosting Agent grants tools according to this declaration, the Skill receives a capability beyond its stated functional requirements. Untrusted note content or task instructions could then influence the Agent into invoking operating-system commands.
Attack Path
- A user or automated workflow loads the Skill.
- The hosting Agent grants the declared
read,write, andexectools. - The Skill processes attacker-controlled note content, metadata, or task instructions.
- Malicious content directs the Agent to perform a system operation as part of the purported note-maintenance workflow.
- Because this package defines no enforceable command allowlist or argument restrictions, the Agent may invoke
execwith attacker-influenced commands. - The command runs with the operating-system privileges and environmental access available to the hosting Agent.
Impact Assessment
Successful exploitation could permit command execution within the Agent's run ...[truncated 618 chars]
- Remediation
View remediation
Remediation Suggestions
- Remove
execfrom the declared tools because it is not required for the stated knowledge-note workflow:yaml tools: - read - write - Restrict read and write operations to the documented
life/areas/**directory and reject path traversal, absolute paths, and symbolic-link escapes. - If command execution is genuinely necessary, document each required command and expose a narrowly scoped operation rather than unrestricted shell access.
- Implement a strict command allowlist using fixed executable paths and structured argument arrays. Do not concatenate user-controlled values into shell command strings.
- Disable shell interpretation and prohibit command substitutions, pipes, redirections, metacharacters, and environment-variable expansion.
- Enforce sandboxing at runtime with minimal filesystem permissions, no unnecessary network access, a sanitized environment, resource limits, and a non-privileged operating-system account.
- Require explicit user confirmation before any command with side effects and record security-relevant executions in an audit log.
- Add automated tests confirming that unapproved commands, path escapes, and attacker-controlled arguments are rejected.
- Remove
