T05 · Unauthorized Access and Privilege Escalation
- Location
SKILL.md:268- Finding
Unnecessary Automatic Network Diagnostics Through Execution Privileges
- Content
View full analysis
Vulnerability Details
File Location:
SKILL.md:5andSKILL.md:268
Vulnerability Type: Excessive tool permissions and automatic network probing
Risk Level: MediumVulnerable Configuration and Instruction
yaml allowed-tools: read exectext - 执行ping命令测试网络连通性,检查防火墙和代理设置连接后重新执行命令机制: 失败时自动执行ping命令测试网络连通性,检查防火墙和代理设置连接后重新执行命令, 最多3次 - 处理方式: 按上述步骤操作并确认结果The instruction at line 268 directs the agent to automatically execute
ping, inspect firewall and proxy settings, reconnect, and retry up to three times after a failure.Technical Analysis
The skill is presented as a Markdown-based Go programming guidance tool. Its legitimate functions involve reviewing Go code and explaining language pitfalls; they do not inherently require operating-system command execution, network probing, or inspection of host connectivity configuration.
Nevertheless, line 5 grants the broad
exectool, while line 268 directs the agent to invoke network diagnostics automatically. The instruction does not define an approved destination, constrain command arguments, require user confirmation, or specify a safe non-shell execution mechanism. This violates least-privilege principles and gives failure handling capabilities beyond the skill's declared purpose.The document does not itself contain shell interpolation or a concrete attacker-controlled command template, so direct command injection is not proven. However, an implementation that derives the diagnostic destination or command arguments from user input could expose a command-injection surface. Even without injection, automatic probing can reveal whether internal or external systems are reachable and may expose local firewall or proxy configuration through the agent's output.
Attack Path
- A user invokes the skill for a Go-related operation that fails or can be made to appear to fail.
- The failure-handling instruction activates automatically.
- Using ...[truncated 1649 chars]
- Remediation
View remediation
Remediation Suggestions
- Remove automatic
ping, firewall inspection, proxy inspection, and reconnection behavior from the generic error-handling instructions. - Remove
execfromallowed-toolsif the skill is intended only to provide Go guidance and review source supplied by the user. - If execution is necessary to compile or test Go code, expose only narrowly scoped commands and separate code validation from network diagnostics.
- Require explicit user approval before performing any network operation or examining host network configuration.
- Restrict diagnostic destinations to validated hostnames or IP addresses from an explicit allowlist.
- Invoke diagnostic programs directly with structured argument arrays rather than through a shell. Reject shell metacharacters, options, and unexpected argument forms.
- Apply execution timeouts, output limits, retry limits, and process isolation.
- Run permitted commands in a sandbox with minimal filesystem access, no sensitive environment variables, and restricted network access.
- Redact internal addresses, proxy credentials, and sensitive configuration values from diagnostic output.
- Replace the current automatic behavior with a passive error message explaining that the user may independently verify connectivity when relevant.
- Remove automatic
