T05 · Unauthorized Access and Privilege Escalation
- Location
SKILL.md:10- Finding
Excessive Filesystem and Shell Permissions for Cron Expression Processing
- Content
View full analysis
Vulnerability Details
File Location:
SKILL.md, lines 10-13; related privilege-escalation guidance at line 476
Vulnerability Type: Violation of least privilege
Risk Level: MediumComplete Code Snippet:
yaml tools: - Read - Write - Edit - BashLine 476 additionally advises users experiencing permission errors to check file permissions and run with administrator privileges.
Technical Analysis
The Skill's declared functionality consists of parsing, translating, validating, optimizing, previewing, and converting cron expressions. These operations are primarily deterministic text and date calculations. They do not inherently require arbitrary shell execution or unrestricted modification of project and system files.
Declaring
Write,Edit, andBashtherefore grants capabilities beyond the minimum privileges needed for the stated task. The generic recommendation to run with administrator privileges can further increase the impact of an unsafe or mistakenly generated tool call. The document does not define a specific privileged operation, restrict writable paths, provide a command allowlist, or require explicit user approval before shell execution.The permissions alone do not prove malicious execution, and the audited file contains no command that installs a cron job. However, broad tools create an avoidable security boundary violation if untrusted cron input or contextual instructions influence the agent's actions.
Attack Path
- A user or untrusted document supplies a crafted request while this Skill is active.
- The request persuades the agent that it must inspect files, modify scheduler configuration, or invoke a shell to process or migrate the cron expression.
- Because the Skill declares
Read,Write,Edit, andBash, the agent may access files or execute commands unrelated to expression analysis. - If the operator follows the line 476 recommendation to r ...[truncated 1019 chars]
- Remediation
View remediation
Remediation Suggestions
- Remove
Write,Edit, andBashfrom the declared tools. RetainReadonly if the Skill must load cron expressions from existing files; otherwise, remove it as well. - Implement expression parsing, validation, timezone handling, and format conversion without invoking external commands.
- Remove the generic recommendation to run as administrator. Privilege errors should instead result in a safe failure with an explanation of the narrowly required access.
- If file export is a required feature, use a dedicated, path-scoped write capability restricted to a user-selected output file.
- If shell execution is introduced for a documented feature, require explicit per-command user approval, use a strict command and argument allowlist, reject shell metacharacters, and execute under an unprivileged account.
- Explicitly state that the Skill converts cron expressions but does not install crontab entries, create scheduled tasks, or register services unless the user separately requests and approves that operation.
- Remove
