T09 · Insecure Skill Coding Practices
- Location
vision_cast.py:76- Finding
Projection Functions Report Successful Secure Delivery Without Performing Any Transfer
- Content
View full analysis
Vulnerability Details
File Location:
vision_cast.py, lines 76-80; success output is generated at lines 105-116
Vulnerability Type: False security and delivery claims
Risk Level: MediumVulnerable Code
python def cast_via_dlna(self, media_url: str) -> dict: return {"protocol": "UPnP/DLNA", "target": self.target_ip, "status": "Dispatched"} def push_secure_snapshot(self, image_path: str, token: str) -> dict: return {"protocol": "S2_Secure_REST", "status": "Snapshot_Pushed", "privacy": "Ephemeral_30s"}The returned values are subsequently presented as successful authorized operations:
python elif args.mode == "dlna_cast": core_tensors = dispatcher.cast_via_dlna(args.media_url) vendor_nl = "UPnP SOAP command dispatched. / UPnP指令已下发。" elif args.mode == "snapshot_push": core_tensors = dispatcher.push_secure_snapshot(args.payload, vision_token) vendor_nl = "Snapshot dispatched via S2 Fallback. / 已通过S2兜底协议推送加密快照。" print(json.dumps({ "status": "AUTHORIZED_VISION_CAST", "architecture_compliance": "SNIFF_FIRST_PUSH_LATER_NO_SERVER",Technical Analysis
Neither projection method implements the operation it claims to perform. The DLNA method does not construct or transmit a UPnP SOAP request. The snapshot method does not:
- Open or validate the supplied image.
- Connect to the target device.
- Encrypt the image.
- Use the supplied authentication token.
- Receive delivery confirmation.
- Implement or verify deletion after 30 seconds.
Despite this, the methods return
Dispatched,Snapshot_Pushed, andEphemeral_30s, and the main routine reportsAUTHORIZED_VISION_CAST. This is a fail-open reporting design: unperformed or failed security-sensitive actions are represented as successful.The behavior directly contradicts the documented secure-push and ephemeral-deletion guarantees. It can cause an agent or operator to make confidenti ...[truncated 1359 chars]
- Remediation
View remediation
Remediation Suggestions
- Implement the documented network protocols before returning a success state.
- For DLNA, validate
media_url, construct the required UPnP SOAP request, enforce connection and read timeouts, and check the receiver's HTTP and SOAP response. - For snapshot delivery, validate the image path and type, encrypt the content using an authenticated encryption scheme, authenticate the receiver, and use the token only through a documented authorization protocol.
- Require positive receiver acknowledgement before returning
Snapshot_Pushed. - Implement receiver-side expiry and deletion, then distinguish between requested expiry and confirmed deletion.
- Return explicit states such as
not_implemented,delivery_failed,delivery_unconfirmed, anddeletion_unconfirmed. - Never emit
AUTHORIZED_VISION_CAST,Dispatched, orEphemeral_30sunless the corresponding operation has been completed and verified. - Add integration tests using a controlled receiver to verify transfer, authentication, failure handling, and deletion behavior.
