T09 · Insecure Skill Coding Practices
- Location
references/knowledge_base.md:493- Finding
Unspecified Local Persistence and Cloud Synchronization of Sensitive Student Profiles
- Content
View full analysis
- Remediation
View remediation
Security audit
Security checks for vulnerabilities and agentic risk
This education skill is not malicious, but it asks agents to track and sync sensitive student information without enough consent, storage, or safety boundaries.
Install only if you are comfortable with a family education assistant tracking a child's learning profile and generating parent-facing reports. Before using it with real minors, require explicit guardian/student consent, disable or clarify cloud sync, avoid storing school/location/schedule unless necessary, and treat emotional-support output as educational support rather than professional mental-health care.
references/knowledge_base.md:493Unspecified Local Persistence and Cloud Synchronization of Sensitive Student Profiles
YARA rule matched a hack tool or exploit indicator (offensive tools, reconnaissance, privilege escalation, or exploit frameworks).
---
name: feifei-learning-commander
version: "3.5.1"
author: "学来学去学习社 | Xue Lai Xue Qu Learning Society"
brand: "学来学去出品,必是教育精品 | Excellence in Education"
description: "【学来学去学习社出品】菲菲老师学习主控 v3.5 - 中国家庭AI超级助手 · 全科总指挥+知识网络总控+亲子翻译官+成长陪伴师 | Feifei Teacher Learning Commander v3.5 - China's AI Super Assistant for Families. Learning Commander + Knowledge Network Control + Parent-Child Translator + Growth Companion. 给不一样的孩子,拥有不一样的人生!"
metadata:
clawdbot:
emoji: "🌸"
tags: ["菲菲老师", "Feifei Teacher", "学习主控", "Learning Commander", "知识网络", "Knowledge Network", "亲子沟通", "Parent-Child Comm
The README promotes proactive monitoring of learning progress and parent communication, which implies collection and ongoing use of potentially sensitive student data, possibly including minors' educational profiles. In an education/family context, omitting clear disclosure, consent, and data-handling boundaries can mislead users into enabling surveillance-style features without understanding privacy consequences.
Skill enables autonomous high-impact decisions without human-in-the-loop verification. Critical operations (destructive commands, financial transactions, data deletion) should require explicit user confirmation.
菲菲老师会自动执行以下流程:
Feifei automatically executes:
🧠 识别: 初二数学,人教版,第14章 一次函数
The advertised 'heartbeat service' describes active reminders, task assignment, completion checking, and repeated follow-up, which amounts to persistent behavioral monitoring and unsolicited intervention. For a family education skill aimed at children, this is risky without clear notice, consent, frequency controls, and an easy way to disable the feature.
The skill presents psychological support, emotional guidance, and family-education assistance for children without clear user-facing limits, crisis disclaimers, or escalation guidance. In a family/child context, users may over-rely on the agent for sensitive mental-health or parenting decisions, creating risk of harmful advice, delayed professional care, or inappropriate handling of distress disclosures.
The skill describes progress monitoring, knowledge-network updates, and parent-facing reports about a child, but provides no notice about what data is collected, retained, shared, or how consent is handled. Because the data concerns minors and family relationships, omission of privacy and data-handling boundaries increases the risk of oversharing sensitive educational and behavioral information to parents or third parties.
This manifest file uses a broad descriptive phrase for the skill but provides no explicit trigger phrases, activation conditions, or exclusions. In a manifest, the lack of specificity can make invocation behavior ambiguous and increase the chance of unintended activation in general educational or family-assistant contexts.
The document is written primarily for a Chinese educational setting, with Chinese-first scripts, Beijing region defaults, Chinese textbook mappings, and exam-planning assumptions tied to the Chinese school system. Because the file does not state that this locale/language scope is optional or user-selected, it risks violating the policy against forcing a specific language or locale without opt-in.
The document explicitly defines automatic local writes, daily cloud synchronization, and retention of recent historical versions for student profile data, which includes identifiable and sensitive educational information. In a family/child-focused assistant context, undisclosed persistence and cloud transfer materially increase privacy, consent, and compliance risk, especially for minors.
The natural-language description presents the skill as "China's AI Super Assistant for Families," and the name is primarily Chinese, which suggests a locale-specific orientation. Because the manifest does not state that users can choose language/locale or explain a justified region-specific constraint, this may conflict with language/locale neutrality expectations.
The text says all templates support only Chinese/English bilingual output, which sets a specific language policy for the skill output. Under the policy rule, forcing a specific language or locale without user opt-in is a natural-language policy concern unless the user is offered a choice or the restriction is clearly justified.