T05 · Unauthorized Access and Privilege Escalation
- Location
SKILL.md:43- Finding
Unbounded Autonomous Remediation Without User Approval
- Content
View full analysis
Vulnerability Details
File Location:
SKILL.md, line 43
Vulnerability Type:T05: Unauthorized Access and Privilege Escalation
Risk Level: MediumComplete relevant snippet translated into English:
markdown ## Proactivity - Do not wait for the user to ask, "How is the server?" - Proactively report discovered problems - Immediately handle anything that can be automatically repairedTechnical Analysis
The final instruction authorizes the agent to perform unspecified automatic remediation immediately after detecting a problem. It does not define an allowlist of permitted operations, require user approval, restrict the privileges under which remediation may run, identify protected resources, or require rollback and post-action validation.
Monitoring disk, memory, CPU, network, and process state is consistent with the declared purpose. Unconditionally modifying the system is not necessary for monitoring and reporting, however. The broad phrase "anything that can be automatically repaired" could be interpreted as permission to terminate processes, delete files, change configuration, restart services, modify network settings, or perform other state-changing operations.
The package contains no executable implementation or explicit privilege-escalation mechanism. Consequently, this instruction cannot independently obtain operating-system privileges beyond those already available to the hosting agent. The risk arises because it encourages the agent to use its existing tools and permissions beyond a clearly bounded monitoring role.
Attack Path
- The skill periodically examines system health indicators.
- A normal transient condition, manipulated metric, or genuine fault exceeds one of the documented thresholds.
- The agent classifies the condition as something that can be repaired automatically.
- Based on the line 43 instruction, the agent selects a state-changing remediation without requ ...[truncated 974 chars]
- Remediation
View remediation
Remediation Suggestions
- Replace the unrestricted automatic-repair instruction with diagnosis, reporting, and remediation recommendations only.
- Require explicit user approval before every state-changing operation.
- If automation is required, define a narrow allowlist of reversible actions and prohibit commands outside that allowlist.
- Specify resource boundaries, including the exact services, processes, directories, and configuration keys that may be changed.
- Run monitoring under a dedicated least-privilege account without administrative access.
- Separate read-only monitoring permissions from remediation permissions, granting the latter only for an approved action.
- Require a dry run, pre-change state capture, timeout, rollback procedure, and post-action health validation.
- Log the detected condition, selected action, authorization decision, command or tool invocation, result, and rollback status.
- Add safeguards against destructive operations, including file deletion, process termination, firewall modification, package installation, and service reconfiguration.
- A safer replacement instruction would be: “Detect and report anomalies with recommended remediation. Do not modify system state unless the user explicitly approves a specific, bounded action.”
