T08 · Insecure Dependencies
- Location
README.md:18- Finding
Mismatched Installation Command Can Install an Unreviewed Package
- Content
View full analysis
- Remediation
View remediation
Security audit
Security checks for vulnerabilities and agentic risk
This looks like a coaching prompt rather than malware, but its package identity is inconsistent and it tells agents to save sensitive coaching profiles without clear consent controls.
Review before installing. The package should correct its name, README, install command, repository URL, tags, and reference files so they consistently describe the same ESFJ skill. It should also make saved coaching records opt-in, show users what will be saved, and provide clear review/delete controls.
README.md:18Mismatched Installation Command Can Install an Unreviewed Package
SKILL.md:283Automatic Persistence of Potentially Sensitive Coaching Profiles Without Defined Safeguards
The README identifies the skill as an INTP coach while the manifest says the skill is for ESFJ users, creating a material mismatch between declared purpose and documented behavior. This can cause the wrong skill to be invoked or trusted for the wrong audience, leading to unsafe or inappropriate guidance and undermining user and platform expectations about what the skill does.
Nearly the entire documented behavior targets INTP-specific coaching patterns rather than the manifest's ESFJ-focused purpose, indicating a broad scope integrity failure rather than a minor typo. In an agent ecosystem, this can misroute sensitive self-help interactions, produce systematically mismatched advice, and defeat any policy review or user consent based on the manifest description.
Marking 'growth record' as 'automatic execution' implies stateful storage or logging may occur without a clearly bounded user action. In a coaching context, this is especially risky because conversations may contain sensitive emotional, behavioral, or mental-health-adjacent information that should not be retained by default.
The README states that conversations and actions are saved but provides no clear warning about data retention, privacy consequences, or handling of sensitive personal content. This creates a meaningful privacy risk because users may disclose intimate self-improvement or psychological concerns without understanding that the information is being persisted.
The manifest metadata materially conflicts with the stated purpose of the skill: the package is named 'esfj-coach' but its description, keywords, and tags point to an INTP-focused coaching tool. This kind of identity mismatch is dangerous because users, reviewers, or automated systems may trust the declared skill purpose while actually installing or invoking something different, which increases the risk of deceptive packaging, incorrect routing, and hidden malicious or inappropriate behavior in associated files.
The reference file is entirely focused on INTP coaching, while the skill metadata says the skill is for ESFJ-specific growth guidance. This mismatch can cause the agent to deliver guidance optimized for the wrong personality type, undermining reliability and potentially causing harmful or misleading advice in a coaching context where users may rely on tailored psychological framing.
All user-facing instructions, examples, and behavior descriptions are written in Chinese, and the README does not indicate that users can choose another language. This can constitute a language-policy issue when a skill effectively forces a specific language without opt-in or justification.
Describing mode selection as 'automatic recognition' without clear trigger boundaries or exclusions leaves activation behavior ambiguous. Ambiguous invocation rules can cause the skill to engage unexpectedly, choose the wrong mode for sensitive conversations, or interfere with other skills because users and reviewers cannot predict when it will act.
The skill advertises a "成长记录" capability that saves dialogue and action history, which implies persistence of potentially sensitive personal data such as emotional state, goals, and behavioral patterns. Because the skill does not clearly warn the user up front, obtain consent, or define storage scope/retention, users may disclose sensitive information without understanding it will be archived.
This section instructs the agent to record a user profile containing core problems, interests, action records, and key insights from coaching conversations. In a coaching context, these details can reveal sensitive psychological and personal information, and collecting them without explicit notice and consent increases privacy risk and the chance of inappropriate profiling or retention.
The end-of-conversation workflow directs the system to archive key user information automatically at session close, including the user's problem, insights, action plan, and outcomes. Automatic archival at the end of a vulnerable coaching exchange is risky because users may interpret the interaction as ephemeral unless clearly told otherwise and given a chance to decline.
The repository URL points to an unrelated project ('women-awakening-museum') rather than a repository that clearly corresponds to the declared ESFJ coaching skill. An unrelated source reference breaks provenance and traceability, making it harder to verify authorship, review source history, or detect substituted content; in a supply-chain context, this can conceal tampering or facilitate trust abuse.
This markdown reference is written entirely in Chinese and is described as internal guidance for the skill at runtime. Because the skill consumes it as behavioral context and there is no indication that users can opt into another language or that the skill is intentionally region-specific, this may impose a language/locale constraint without user choice.
The document is labeled as ESFJ guidance, but the traits and function descriptions largely map to a different profile, creating a semantic integrity failure in the skill’s reference data. In a coaching skill, this can systematically produce inaccurate or psychologically mismatched advice, especially because the file is explicitly meant for internal guidance rather than direct user scrutiny.
This markdown file contains end-user skill reference content exclusively in Chinese, and nowhere indicates that the user can choose another language or that the skill is intentionally region- or locale-specific. Under the policy, forcing a specific language without user opt-in is a natural-language policy violation.
The file explicitly labels itself as 'INTP Coach' reference data in the later sections, directly contradicting the ESFJ intent declared in the manifest. This strengthens evidence that the skill may be wired to the wrong behavioral framework, increasing the chance of systematic misclassification and inappropriate user guidance.
The documented file path points to a different coach directory, which indicates copy/paste contamination and weak configuration integrity. While this is less severe than the profile mismatch, it increases the chance of loading or maintaining the wrong reference material and signals that the skill may be wired to incorrect assets.