other
- Location
SKILL.md:171- Finding
Unnecessary Transmission of a User Identifier to an Unspecified Network Destination
- Content
View full analysis
Vulnerability Details
File Location:
SKILL.md, lines 171-174
Vulnerability Type: Privacy-sensitive data transmission beyond the Skill's minimum functional scope
Risk Level: MediumVulnerable Code
ts export const trackEvent = (name: string) => { const user = useUserStore() send({ name, uid: user.id }) }Technical Analysis
The example retrieves a user identifier from globally shared application state and passes it to an unspecified
sendfunction. The destination, transport security, authorization, user consent, retention policy, and identifier handling requirements are not defined.The declared purpose of the Skill is to advise on Vue and Pinia state management. Transmitting a user identifier is not necessary to demonstrate obtaining a store after Pinia installation. Consequently, this example exceeds the minimum privileges and data access required for the Skill's stated functionality.
The snippet is documentation rather than an executable implementation, so it does not prove that data is currently being sent to a malicious endpoint. However, an AI agent or developer could copy the pattern into an application and connect
sendto an analytics or telemetry service without appropriate privacy controls.Attack Path
- An agent or developer uses the tracker example while implementing a Vue application.
- The application reads
user.idfrom the globally available user store. - The unspecified
sendfunction is connected to a remote analytics, logging, or telemetry endpoint. - User identifiers are transmitted without explicit consent, destination validation, or data-minimization controls.
- A compromised, incorrectly configured, or untrusted endpoint can collect the identifiers and correlate user activity.
Impact Assessment
Exploitation does not grant local system privileges or code execution. The affected scope is application privacy and confidentiality. A remote ...[truncated 284 chars]
- Remediation
View remediation
Remediation Suggestions
- Replace the networked tracker with a side-effect-free example that demonstrates delayed store access without transmitting user data.
- If telemetry is genuinely required, document and enforce an allowlisted HTTPS destination.
- Do not transmit a direct account identifier by default. Use a short-lived, pseudonymous identifier where correlation is necessary.
- Require explicit user consent where applicable and provide a mechanism to disable telemetry.
- Define permitted event fields, retention limits, access controls, and deletion procedures.
- Validate that event payloads cannot accidentally include tokens, profile data, or other sensitive store fields.
- Make telemetry failure non-blocking and avoid logging complete payloads containing identifiers.
