T09 · Insecure Skill Coding Practices
- Location
scripts/init_audit.sh:8- Finding
Audit Log Truncation During Reinitialization
- Content
View full analysis
Vulnerability Details
File Location:
scripts/init_audit.sh, lines 8 and 17
Vulnerability Type: Unconditional file truncation resulting in audit-record destruction
Risk Level: MediumVulnerable Code
bash JSONL="$AUDIT_DIR/$TODAY.jsonl"bash : > "$JSONL"Technical Analysis
The script computes the current daily audit-log path and then unconditionally redirects an empty command into that file. In POSIX-compatible shells,
: > "$JSONL"creates the file if it does not exist but truncates it to zero bytes if it already exists.Unlike the index and summary files initialized later in the script, this operation does not first check whether the daily log already exists. Consequently, every subsequent invocation on the same day erases all events previously written to that day's JSONL file. This contradicts the project's stated purpose of maintaining a reliable operational audit trail.
No privilege escalation is involved. Exploitation requires the ability to run the initialization script against a root directory containing an existing audit structure.
Attack Path
-
Audit events are written to
ROOT/logs/audit/YYYY-MM-DD.jsonl. -
An operator, scheduled workflow, or actor with script-execution access invokes:
bash scripts/init_audit.sh ROOT -
The script resolves
JSONLto the existing current-day log. -
Line 17 executes
: > "$JSONL". -
The existing file is silently reduced to zero bytes, destroying all audit events recorded in it.
Impact Assessment
The issue permits deletion of the current day's audit records within any writable root directory supplied to the script. It does not grant additional system privileges, network access, or access to otherwise protected files.
The security impact is loss of audit integrity and availability. Relevant evidence may be erased, reducing traceability and potentially concealing earlier administrative, publication, configuration, or credential-related acti ...[truncated 117 chars]
-
- Remediation
View remediation
Remediation Suggestions
Preserve an existing daily log and create it only when absent. The simplest safe implementation is:
bash touch "$JSONL"Alternatively, follow the conditional initialization pattern already used for the other files:
bash [ -f "$JSONL" ] || : > "$JSONL"Additional hardening should include:
- Document that initialization is idempotent and must never remove existing audit data.
- Add a regression test that writes an event, reruns the script, and verifies that the event remains intact.
- Consider refusing to operate on symbolic-link log files if the script may run in directories writable by untrusted users.
- If intentional reset behavior is needed, expose it through an explicit option such as
--reset, display a warning, and create a backup before truncation.
