T09 · Insecure Skill Coding Practices
Warning
- Location
roundtable_notifier.py:69- Finding
User Confirmation Gate Is Bypassed by an Unconditional Success Result
- Content
View full analysis
bool: """ Send RoundTable confirmation request. Note: The caller is responsible for actually waiting for confirmation. """ message = ( f"🔄 **RoundTable multi-Agent deep discussion**\n\n" f"**Discussion topic**: {self.topic}\n\n" f"📋 **Discussion details**:\n" f"- Participating Agents: {', '.join(engine.agents[:5])}\n" f"- Discussion rounds: five rounds (R1-R5)\n" f"- Estimated duration: **10-30 minutes**\n" f"- Output: complete proposal, multiple viewpoints, and recommendations\n\n" f"⚠️ **Notice**:\n" f"- RoundTable is intended for scenarios requiring deep analysis\n" f"- Use ordinary conversation if a fast answer is needed\n" f"- Progress can be viewed while the discussion is running\n\n" f"**Please confirm your request**:\n" f'Reply "**Confirm**" to start the RoundTable discussion\n' f'Reply "**Quick**" to receive a short proposal' ) self._send_message(engine, user_channel, message) print(f"Confirmation request sent to {user_channel}") # This method only sends the request and does not wait for a reply. # The caller is expected to implement actual confirmation handling. # In the current demonstration mode, execution continues directly. return True ``` The returned value is consumed as an authorization decision in `roundtable_engine.py:129-132`: ```python confirmed = await self.notifier.send_confirmation_request(self, user_channel) if not confirmed: print("User cancelled RoundTable") return False ``` ### Technical Analysis The notification explicitly instructs the user to reply with confirma ...[truncated 2177 chars]- Remediation
View remediation
bool: if not confirmed: await self.notifier.send_confirmation_request(self, user_channel) return False ``` 4. Bind authorization to the exact operation, including: - Requesting user identity. - Destination channel. - Discussion topic or a cryptographic digest of it. - Timestamp and expiration. - Unique operation ID. 5. Add tests proving that: - No `sessions_spawn` call occurs before confirmed authorization. - Responses from a different user or channel are rejected. - Expired and replayed confirmations are rejected. - Delivery failure cannot be interpreted as consent. ]]>