T09 · Insecure Skill Coding Practices
- Location
scripts/cn_hash_generator.py:58- Finding
HMAC Secret Exposed Through Command-Line Arguments
- Content
View full analysis
Vulnerability Details
File Location:
scripts/cn_hash_generator.py, lines 58 and 100-103
Vulnerability Type: Sensitive information exposure through process arguments and shell history
Risk Level: MediumVulnerable Code
python parser.add_argument('--hmac', metavar='KEY', help='HMAC密钥')python # HMAC模式 if args.hmac: result = hmac_sign(args.text, args.hmac, args.algo) if result: print(result.upper() if args.upper else result) returnTechnical Analysis
The interface requires users to supply an HMAC signing key directly through the
--hmaccommand-line option. Command-line arguments are not an appropriate transport for sensitive cryptographic material because they may be:- Recorded in the user's shell history.
- Visible through operating-system process inspection while the command is running.
- Captured by process-monitoring, audit, telemetry, or job-orchestration systems.
- Included in debugging output, execution logs, or terminal session records.
The key is used locally and is not transmitted by the script. Nevertheless, its placement in the process argument vector unnecessarily exposes it beyond the cryptographic operation. This exceeds the minimum exposure necessary for the declared HMAC functionality.
The project does not access the network, elevate privileges, or persist the key. Exploitation therefore depends on an attacker or monitoring system having access to the user's command history, process metadata, or execution logs.
Attack Path
- A user invokes the utility with a sensitive key, for example:
bash python3 scripts/cn_hash_generator.py "message" --hmac "production-secret" - The shell records the complete command in its history, or the operating system exposes the argument vector while the process is running.
- A local attacker, administrator, monitoring agent, or other party with access to that history or ...[truncated 938 chars]
- Remediation
View remediation
Remediation Suggestions
- Accept HMAC keys through a non-echoing interactive prompt using Python's
getpass.getpass(). - Provide an option to read the key from standard input or a dedicated file descriptor so it does not appear in the process argument vector.
- If file-based secret input is supported, require restrictive file permissions and avoid printing the key or including it in error messages.
- Avoid environment variables for high-value long-lived secrets where possible, because environment data may also be exposed through process inspection or diagnostic systems.
- Retain
--hmaconly for non-sensitive testing if backward compatibility is required, and emit a clear warning that command-line keys may be recorded or observed. - Update documentation with a safe invocation pattern, such as prompting securely for the key.
- Ensure logs, exceptions, and diagnostic output never include the key.
- Encourage key rotation if a production key has previously been supplied through the command-line interface.
- Accept HMAC keys through a non-echoing interactive prompt using Python's
