T05 · Unauthorized Access and Privilege Escalation
- Location
SKILL.md:276- Finding
Unconditional Git Staging and Commit May Capture Unrelated Repository Changes
- Content
View full analysis
Vulnerability Details
File Location:
SKILL.md, lines 276–279
Vulnerability Type: Unauthorized repository modification and excessive staging scope
Risk Level: MediumVulnerable Code
markdown Always commit test improvements: ```bash git add sources/ tests/ git commit -m "Improve test coverage for <module>"text ### Technical Analysis The skill instructs the agent to always stage and commit changes after improving test coverage. This behavior is unnecessary for coverage analysis and violates least-privilege principles because it changes repository state and Git history without requiring explicit user authorization. The staging command operates on the complete `sources/` and `tests/` directory trees rather than on files modified specifically by the current task. Consequently, pre-existing changes—including unrelated, incomplete, sensitive, or unreviewed work—may be incorporated into the generated commit. Although the instructions do not grant operating-system privileges or execute remote code, they authorize repository modifications beyond the minimum scope needed to perform coverage analysis. ### Attack Path 1. A user has pre-existing uncommitted changes under `sources/` or `tests/`. 2. The user asks an agent using this skill to analyze or improve test coverage. 3. The agent follows the mandatory instruction to run `git add sources/ tests/`. 4. Git stages both the agent's intended test changes and the user's unrelated modifications. 5. The agent runs the prescribed `git commit` without obtaining explicit approval. 6. The resulting commit records all staged content, potentially exposing or preserving unrelated sensitive work in local or subsequently pushed history. This path requires the agent to follow the documented workflow and requires unrelated modifications to exist within one of the broadly staged directories. ### Impact Assessment The behavior can modify the active repository's index and local commit history. Its scope ...[truncated 636 chars]- Remediation
View remediation
Remediation Suggestions
- Remove the unconditional requirement to commit changes.
- Treat repository commits as an optional action requiring explicit user approval.
- Before requesting approval, display the relevant diff and clearly list the files that would be staged.
- Stage only files created or modified by the current task, using explicit paths rather than entire directories.
- Recheck the staged diff with
git diff --cachedbefore committing. - Preserve unrelated working-tree and index changes.
- Replace the current instructions with a guarded workflow such as:
markdown After making test improvements: 1. Show the user the files changed and the relevant diff. 2. Do not stage or commit changes unless the user explicitly requests it. 3. If approved, stage only the files modified for this task: `git add -- <explicit-file-paths>` 4. Review `git diff --cached` before creating the commit.
