T09 · Insecure Skill Coding Practices
- Location
scripts/bedtime_story_tail.sh:79- Finding
Unbounded Delay Allows Resource Exhaustion and Arithmetic Failure
- Content
View full analysis
Vulnerability Details
File Location:
scripts/bedtime_story_tail.sh, lines 79–85
Vulnerability Type: Improper input validation and uncontrolled resource consumption
Risk Level: MediumVulnerable Code
bash if ! [[ "$DELAY_MINUTES" =~ ^[0-9]+$ ]]; then echo "--delay-minutes must be an integer" >&2 exit 1 fi echo "$LOG_PREFIX sleeping for $DELAY_MINUTES minutes before bedtime ending sequence..." sleep "$((DELAY_MINUTES * 60))"Technical Analysis
The script validates
DELAY_MINUTESonly as a sequence of decimal digits. It does not impose a minimum or maximum value, limit input length, or verify that multiplication by 60 remains within Bash's signed integer range.The documented workflow supports user-selected
N-minute stop delays, so an untrusted or accidental request can be translated into the--delay-minutesargument. A large accepted value causes the script to remain in a foregroundsleepfor an excessive period. An extremely long numeric value can also overflow Bash arithmetic or produce a duration rejected bysleep, preventing the intended stop and screen-off sequence.The arguments are correctly quoted, so this is not command injection. The issue is insufficient numeric range validation and use of a long-lived process as a scheduling mechanism.
Attack Path
- A user requests an extremely large delay before stopping bedtime media.
- The Agent or invoking process passes that value through
--delay-minutes. - The digits-only regular expression accepts the value.
- The script evaluates
DELAY_MINUTES * 60. - The process either enters an excessively long sleep or encounters arithmetic overflow or an invalid sleep duration.
- The intended pause and screen-off commands are delayed indefinitely or never executed.
- If multiple runs are launched independently or in the background, sleeping processes can accumulate and consume process-table and execution resources.
Impact Assessment
Exploitation doe ...[truncated 569 chars]
- Remediation
View remediation
Remediation Suggestions
Enforce a strict operational range before performing arithmetic. Also limit the accepted string length so an oversized integer cannot reach Bash arithmetic evaluation.
For example:
bash if ! [[ "$DELAY_MINUTES" =~ ^[0-9]{1,3}$ ]] || (( DELAY_MINUTES < 1 || DELAY_MINUTES > 240 )); then echo "--delay-minutes must be an integer between 1 and 240" >&2 exit 1 fi delay_seconds=$((DELAY_MINUTES * 60)) sleep "$delay_seconds"Additional hardening measures:
- Select a maximum delay appropriate to the product's bedtime-use requirements.
- Reject zero if immediate cleanup is not an intended mode.
- Prefer a managed scheduler or job queue with cancellation, deduplication, timeout enforcement, and status tracking over a long-lived foreground process.
- Prevent multiple pending cleanup jobs for the same device where the runtime supports job management.
- Add boundary tests for zero, the maximum accepted value, one value above the maximum, very long numeric strings, signs, decimals, and nonnumeric input.
- Make the documented default consistent: the implementation uses 15 minutes, while the help text and some test documentation state 5 minutes.
