T03 · Remote Payload Retrieval and Execution
Error
- Location
- references/tools/INSTALLATION.md:219
- Finding
- Unverified Remote Python Payload Downloaded and Installed as a System Command<![CDATA[ ## Vulnerability Details **File Location**: `references/tools/INSTALLATION.md:219-231` **Vulnerability Type**: Remote payload retrieval through HTTP or a mutable GitHub branch **Risk Level**: Critical ### Vulnerable Code ```bash wget http://cgmartini.nl/images/tools/insane/insane.py wget https://github.com/Tsjerk/Insane/raw/master/insane.py chmod +x insane.py sudo mv insane.py /usr/local/bin/insane insane --help ``` ### Technical Analysis The instructions retrieve an executable Python file directly from an external server. The first source uses plaintext HTTP, which provides no transport integrity and is vulnerable to interception or content substitution. The fallback source uses the mutable `master` branch of a personal GitHub repository rather than a fixed commit or signed release. No checksum, digital signature, release tag, or immutable commit is verified before the file is made executable and installed under `/usr/local/bin`. The verification command then executes the downloaded payload. This behavior creates a direct time-of-review versus time-of-execution gap: the effective code run by the user can change without any modification to this Skill package. ### Attack Path 1. An attacker intercepts the plaintext HTTP request, compromises the hosting server, or compromises the GitHub repository. 2. The attacker replaces `insane.py` with a modified Python payload. 3. A user follows the installation instructions and downloads the substituted file. 4. The user marks the payload executable and moves it into `/usr/local/bin`. 5. The `insane --help` verification command or a subsequent membrane workflow executes the payload. 6. The payload runs with the privileges of the invoking user and can access that user's files, simulation data, environment variables, and network resources. 7. Because the command is installed globally, other users or privileged workflows may later invoke the substituted executable. ### Impact Assessment The initial paylo ...[truncated 589 chars]
- Remediation
- <![CDATA[ ## Remediation Suggestions 1. Remove the plaintext HTTP download entirely. 2. Do not download executable code from a mutable branch. 3. Use an official, immutable release artifact or pin an audited Git commit. 4. Publish and verify a SHA-256 checksum or cryptographic signature before installation. 5. Prefer an authenticated package repository with version and hash pinning. 6. Install into a dedicated virtual environment, Conda environment, or user-local directory rather than `/usr/local/bin`. 7. Do not require `sudo` for this workflow. 8. Inspect downloaded code before its first execution. 9. Fail closed if integrity verification cannot be completed. ]]>
