T07 · Tool Hijacking and Spoofing
- Location
scripts/security_scanner.py:12- Finding
Unverified External Python Modules Can Be Loaded and Executed
- Content
View full analysis
- Remediation
View remediation
Security audit
Security checks for vulnerabilities and agentic risk
This security-auditor skill has a coherent purpose, but it relies on unreviewed external Python code and includes persistent configuration-changing behavior that is under-disclosed.
Review this before installing. The audit/reporting goal is legitimate, but do not rely on the scanner unless the external `osa` dependency is pinned and verified. Avoid the aggressive profile except in disposable isolated tests, and treat the fixer as a persistent config editor despite the read-only safety claim.
scripts/security_scanner.py:12Unverified External Python Modules Can Be Loaded and Executed
scripts/report_generator.py:242Unescaped Scan Results Permit Stored HTML Injection
Security Score: {results['score']}/100
Configuration File: {results['config_path']}
Security Mode: {results['mode']}
Total Checks: {results['total_checks']}
Passed: {results['passed_checks']}
Issues Found: {len(results['issues'])}
""" # Add issues for issue in results['issues']: severity = issue.get('severity', 'info') html += f"""Description: {issue.get('description' ...[truncated 2857 chars]
If the skill claims to perform security diagnosis, scoring, validation, and remediation generation but in reality only renders provided values, users can be misled into relying on nonexistent security analysis. In a security context, false assurance is itself harmful because serious misconfigurations may go undetected while the output appears authoritative.
If the skill claims to perform security diagnosis, scoring, validation, and remediation generation but in reality only renders provided values, users can be misled into relying on nonexistent security analysis. In a security context, false assurance is itself harmful because serious misconfigurations may go undetected while the output appears authoritative.
Claiming the skill is 'safe and non-destructive' and 'only reads configuration files' directly contradicts earlier documented write and fix capabilities. In a security tool, deceptive or inaccurate safety claims are especially dangerous because they can lower user caution and enable unintended file modification under a veneer of safety.
The module header claims to provide 'safe configuration fixing capabilities,' but one of its built-in profiles applies overtly unsafe settings. This mismatch is dangerous because it creates trust in a security tool that can silently reduce protections, increasing the likelihood of operator error and insecure deployment.
The 'aggressive' profile materially weakens security by binding to LAN, disabling authentication, disabling workspace-only filesystem restrictions, and widening session scope. In a tool presented as a security auditor/fixer, offering this as a normal selectable mode can directly lead users to deploy an insecure configuration under the mistaken belief that it is a stronger hardening option.
The aggressive mode disables authentication and increases network exposure, yet the command-line interface presents it as a standard mode choice without a strong warning or extra friction at the point of use. In the context of a security auditor skill, this is especially dangerous because users may interpret 'aggressive' as stronger security rather than aggressively permissive behavior.
The skill documents code paths that read from a user configuration and write a report to disk, but it does not declare any explicit tool scope such as permissions or allowed-tools. That mismatch weakens the trust boundary for the skill and can lead to broader-than-expected file access when the agent executes the documented workflow.
The documentation says the skill only reads configuration files, but elsewhere it explicitly writes reports and offers scripts that apply fixes. This inconsistency can cause unsafe operator assumptions about non-destructiveness and may lead users to authorize execution they would have declined if the write behavior were disclosed clearly.
Commands invoke sudo or root privileges. Verify this elevated access is necessary and justified.
### Issue: No system firewall
- **Risk**: Network-level attacks
- **Fix**: Enable UFW with `sudo ufw enable`
## Configuration Validation
This code performs a file write that modifies the user's configuration in place. Although the script logs backup creation and success, it does not require user confirmation before applying changes, which is a safety-relevant operation for a config-fixing tool.
This code sets the default report format to "bilingual", and the CLI also defaults to that format, which forces a specific language/locale combination unless the user explicitly overrides it. Under the policy, language or locale constraints should be optional or clearly justified rather than imposed by default.
The report template hardcodes paired English and Chinese headings and text throughout the generated output, reflecting a fixed locale policy in the natural-language content. The file does not present this as an optional language preference or explain a justified compliance need for this locale combination.