Codebase Argus

Portable Codebase Argus agent playbook for evidence-first multi-agent review of GitHub pull requests, CI failures, GitHub Actions logs, GitHub App webhook review, /argus PR comment commands, autofix branch planning, OpenAI/Claude/Gemini/Codex provider tribunals, downstream merge/rebase work, and long-lived fork sync against an upstream repository.

Use this portable agent playbook for evidence-first codebase review across GitHub PRs, CI failures, and downstream fork integration work. It works as an OpenClaw/ClawHub skill, Codex project instruction, Claude Code project instruction, or a plain Markdown playbook for any coding agent that can run local shell commands.

Both upstream and downstream workflows can send the same evidence package to one provider or a multi-agent tribunal.

Fast Path

From a Codebase Argus checkout:

bash

npm install
npm run argus -- review owner/repo#123

For private repositories or higher GitHub API limits:

bash

GITHUB_TOKEN=<read-only-token> npm run argus -- review owner/repo#123

Do not print tokens. Do not write tokens to files.

Upstream PR Review

Default review is deterministic and rule-based:

bash

npm run argus -- review owner/repo#123 --format markdown

Use a policy file when the repository has local rules:

bash

npm run argus -- review owner/repo#123 --policy .codebase-argus.yml

Use API providers when credentials are available in the environment:

bash

OPENAI_API_KEY=<key> npm run argus -- review owner/repo#123 --provider openai-api
ANTHROPIC_API_KEY=<key> npm run argus -- review owner/repo#123 --provider anthropic-api
GEMINI_API_KEY=<key> npm run argus -- review owner/repo#123 --provider gemini-api

Use local CLI providers only in trusted local workspaces:

bash

npm run argus -- review owner/repo#123 --provider codex-cli
npm run argus -- review owner/repo#123 --provider claude-cli
npm run argus -- review owner/repo#123 --provider gemini-cli

For multi-agent review:

bash

npm run argus -- review owner/repo#123 --tribunal openai-api,claude-cli,codex-cli

Treat output as review assistance. Do not approve, merge, push, or post comments automatically unless the user explicitly asks.

CI Failure Review

When the user provides a failing job log or local log file, review it through the same provider system:

bash

npm run argus -- ci-log logs/failure.txt
npm run argus -- ci-log logs/failure.txt --provider codex-cli
npm run argus -- ci-log logs/failure.txt --tribunal codex-cli,claude-cli,gemini-cli

When the user points at a GitHub PR with failing Actions checks, fetch the job logs directly:

bash

GITHUB_TOKEN=<read-only-token> npm run argus -- ci-github owner/repo#123
GITHUB_TOKEN=<read-only-token> npm run argus -- ci-github owner/repo#123 --provider codex-cli

Focus on the first failing command, the most likely root cause, and the smallest fix that can be verified locally.

Autofix Plan

Use autofix-plan when the user asks for suggested fixes, safe automatic repair, or a branch plan for narrow mechanical failures:

bash

npm run argus -- autofix-plan owner/repo#123

The plan covers gated lanes such as npm lockfile refreshes, snapshot updates, and formatter/linter fixes. Treat it as a command plan; do not execute, push, or open a PR unless the user explicitly asks.

GitHub App Webhook Review

For automatic PR review, the deployed Next.js server exposes:

text

POST /api/github/webhook
GET /api/github/app-manifest

Required environment:

bash

GITHUB_WEBHOOK_SECRET=<secret>
GITHUB_APP_ID=<app-id>
GITHUB_APP_PRIVATE_KEY=<pem-or-escaped-pem>

Use GITHUB_APP_PRIVATE_KEY_BASE64 if storing multiline PEM is awkward. The webhook verifies X-Hub-Signature-256, reviews opened, reopened, ready_for_review, and synchronize, ignores draft PRs, posts COMMENT reviews only, and can add inline comments when ARGUS_WEBHOOK_INLINE_COMMENTS=true.

Supported PR comment commands:

text

/argus help
/argus review
/argus ci
/argus autofix
/argus pause
/argus resume

/argus pause applies argus:paused; automatic review skips PRs with that label. /argus resume removes it.

Do not approve, request changes, merge, push, or post comments outside this configured webhook path unless the user explicitly asks.

What To Look For

Prioritize findings with concrete evidence:

• failing or pending checks;
• source changes without matching tests;
• workflow edits, especially pull_request_target;
• auth, token, webhook, payment, signature, or route-handling changes;
• dependency and lockfile changes;
• large PRs that exceed policy gates;
• stacked PRs targeting non-default base branches;
• merge queue states such as blocked, behind, dirty, or unstable;
• agreement between multiple providers.

Low-confidence model-only claims need manual verification before reporting them as facts.

Downstream Fork Sync And Integration Review

For long-lived fork maintenance, use the downstream CLI first:

bash

npm run argus -- downstream owner/upstream me/fork
npm run argus -- downstream owner/upstream me/fork --upstream-branch main --fork-branch feature/demo

For AI CLI review of merge/rebase risk:

bash

npm run argus -- downstream owner/upstream me/fork --fork-branch feature/demo --provider codex-cli
npm run argus -- downstream owner/upstream me/fork --fork-branch feature/demo --tribunal codex-cli,claude-cli,gemini-cli

When the user explicitly asks the agent to perform the downstream integration, use sync. It prints a dry-run plan unless --execute is present:

bash

npm run argus -- sync owner/upstream me/fork --mode merge --fork-branch feature/demo --test "npm test"
npm run argus -- sync owner/upstream me/fork --mode rebase --fork-branch feature/demo --test "npm test" --execute --push --create-pr

Execution rules:

• run downstream with a provider or tribunal first for risky branches;
• prefer a sync branch such as sync/upstream-main;
• push only with explicit --push;
• open a PR only with explicit --create-pr;
• never push directly over the user's original target branch;
• report failed commands, conflicts, and test output without hiding them.

The downstream prompt must consider both integration paths:

• merge upstream into the fork, using git merge-tree conflict evidence;
• rebase the fork on upstream, using temporary worktree rebase simulation;
• patch-equivalent cleanup candidates from git cherry -v;
• semantic patch movement from git range-diff;
• backup, test, and force-with-lease gates before any push.

Use the local dashboard when a human needs to inspect the same evidence visually:

bash

npm run dev

Open the Downstream Fork Sync, Downstream Merge/Rebase Risk, and Downstream Agent Workflow panels. The local analyzer works in .cache/repos and temporary worktrees, and must not push or force-push by itself. Actual sync execution belongs to the CLI sync command and only runs after explicit flags.