T08 · Insecure Dependencies
- Location
SKILL.md:17- Finding
Unverified Community Adapter Supply Chain
- Content
View full analysis
Vulnerability Details
File Location:
SKILL.md, lines 17–19
Vulnerability Type: Unverified third-party component retrieval
Risk Level: Mediumbash # First time: pull community adapters bb-browser site updateTechnical Analysis
The documented quick-start procedure instructs users to download community-maintained adapters with
bb-browser site update. The skill does not identify an authoritative registry or repository, pin adapter versions, specify integrity hashes, require cryptographic signatures, or describe a review and approval process.These adapters are subsequently used through OpenClaw's browser, including browser sessions authenticated to third-party websites. Consequently, compromise of the adapter distribution source or publication of a malicious adapter could introduce attacker-controlled components after the skill itself has been reviewed. The retrieved adapter content is not present in the audited project, so actual malicious behavior or code execution cannot be confirmed from this repository alone.
Attack Path
- An attacker compromises the community adapter distribution source or succeeds in publishing a malicious or modified adapter.
- A user follows the documented quick-start process and runs
bb-browser site update. - The client retrieves the attacker-controlled adapter without any documented signature, checksum, source verification, or version pinning step.
- The user invokes the affected adapter with
--openclaw. - The adapter operates through the user's OpenClaw browser context and may interact with a website for which the user has an active authenticated session.
- Depending on the permissions and behavior supported by the external adapter runtime, the malicious adapter could perform unintended browser actions or return manipulated data.
Impact Assessment
The affected scope includes users who update and execute community adapters. A compromised adapter ...[truncated 466 chars]
- Remediation
View remediation
Remediation Suggestions
- Document the authoritative adapter registry and source repository.
- Pin adapters to explicitly reviewed versions or immutable commit identifiers rather than implicitly accepting the latest community release.
- Require cryptographic signatures and verify package hashes before installation or update.
- Present the adapter source, version, requested capabilities, and integrity status to the user before installation.
- Require explicit confirmation for updates and provide a locked manifest of approved adapters.
- Run adapters in a sandbox with strict origin, network, browser-tab, filesystem, and process-execution restrictions.
- Grant each adapter access only to the website origins and browser capabilities required for its stated purpose.
- Establish source review, publisher verification, revocation, and incident-response processes for community adapters.
- Document how users can inspect, audit, roll back, and remove downloaded adapters.
