Cedh Advisor

Commander (cEDH) Live-Beratung - Banlist, Tutor-Targets, Mana-Rechnung, Combo-Lines

Security Scan

The skill's instructions mostly match a cEDH advice tool, but they reference local files and executable scripts on the user's drive (E:\Base\...) and an offline DB without declaring any required paths or permissions — that mismatch is concerning.

Purpose & Capability

The name/description (cEDH live advice: banlist, tutor targets, mana math, combo lines) aligns with the SKILL.md content. However, the SKILL.md lists local reference resources (E:\Base\mtg_cedh_pro\*.py, E:\Base\mtg_cedh_pro\mtg_offline.db) and a 'Knowledge Graph' entity that imply access to local data/executable scripts which are not declared in the skill metadata (no required config paths, no install). That is inconsistent with a purely instruction-only advisory skill.

Instruction Scope

The runtime instructions include clear, bounded behavior for live advice (ask for hand/board, count mana, one-sentence recommendation). But the 'REFERENZ-MATERIAL' explicitly references local filesystem paths and Python scripts/DB files which would require the agent to read/execute local files. The skill does not declare or justify needing file I/O or code execution; instructions also tell the agent to perform web searches for ban updates. Directives to use/execute local scripts or databases without declaring access are scope creep and a data/execution risk.

Install Mechanism

There is no install spec and no code files. That keeps the runtime footprint minimal — the skill is instruction-only, so nothing will be written to disk by an install step.

Credentials

The skill declares no environment variables or config paths but references specific local files, scripts, and an offline DB. Requesting access to a user's E:\ drive or to run local Python scripts would be disproportionate for a simple advice skill unless the user explicitly provides/permits those resources. The SKILL.md also references a 'Knowledge Graph' entity name without explaining its source.

Persistence & Privilege

always is false (good). The SKILL.md asks maintainers to update the document on ban changes, which is a normal maintenance instruction. There is no instruction that the skill should forcibly persist itself or alter other skills/configs. Autonomous invocation is allowed by platform default and not by itself a problem here.

Scan Findings in Context

[NO_CODE_FILES] expected: The static scanner found no code files because this is an instruction-only skill; however the SKILL.md references local scripts and databases that the scanner could not analyze.

What to consider before installing

This skill looks like a reasonable cEDH advising checklist, but it explicitly points to local files and Python scripts on E:\ (and an offline DB) while declaring no file-access requirements. Before installing or enabling it: (1) ask the author whether those E:\ paths are required and what the scripts do; (2) do not grant the agent blanket access to your filesystem — prefer a sandboxed environment or remove/replace references to local resources; (3) if you want to use local data, verify the referenced scripts and DB content manually for safety; (4) verify the banlist claims against an official source (the SKILL.md's banned-card list may be out of date or incorrect). If the author cannot justify or remove the local-file expectations, treat the skill as untrusted.

🃏 cEDH Advisor Skill

Aktivierung: Wenn Ben nach MTG/cEDH Beratung fragt, Tutor-Targets, Board-Analyse, oder Spielentscheidungen.

---

🚨 HARTE REGELN (VOR JEDER EMPFEHLUNG!)

1. BANLIST CHECK (PFLICHT!)

⚠️ VOR JEDER Kartenempfehlung → Ist die Karte LEGAL?

Commander Banned List (Stand Sept 2024):

Karte	Status	Warum relevant
Mana Crypt	🚫 GEBANNT	War Staple, NICHT mehr empfehlen!
Dockside Extortionist	🚫 GEBANNT	War Top-Treasure-Engine
Jeweled Lotus	🚫 GEBANNT	War Commander-Ramp
Nadu, Winged Wisdom	🚫 GEBANNT	War Combo-Commander

WEITERHIN LEGAL:

• Sol Ring ✅
• Mana Vault ✅
• Grim Monolith ✅
• Chrome Mox ✅
• Mox Diamond ✅
• Ad Nauseam ✅
• Necropotence ✅
• Thassa's Oracle ✅
• Underworld Breach ✅

⚠️ Bei Unsicherheit → Web-Suche "MTG commander banned list [aktuelless Jahr]" ⚠️ NIEMALS aus dem Gedächtnis empfehlen ohne Check!

---

2. LIVE-BERATUNGS-PROTOKOLL

Wenn Ben im SPIEL ist und schnelle Antworten braucht:

SCHRITT 1: SITUATION ERFASSEN
  → Was ist auf dem Board? (Länder, Rocks, Creatures)
  → Was ist in der Hand? (FRAGE wenn nicht gesagt!)
  → Wie viel Mana verfügbar?
  → Welcher Turn?
  → Was spielen die Gegner?

SCHRITT 2: MANA-RECHNUNG
  → Was KANN er mit dem verfügbaren Mana casten?
  → Farbiges Mana zählen (nicht nur total!)
  → BBB ≠ 3 beliebiges Mana!

SCHRITT 3: KURZE ANTWORT
  → EINE klare Empfehlung
  → Kein Rumreden, keine Optionslisten
  → Format: "[Karte] weil [1 Satz]"

---

🎯 TUTOR-TARGET DECISION TREE

Die goldene Regel:

Tutor sucht das, was am WENIGSTEN REDUNDANT ist. Mana Rocks sind redundant (4+ im Deck). Combo-Pieces sind einzigartig (je 1x).

Entscheidungsbaum:

Hat er schon ein Combo-Piece in Hand?
├── JA → Such das FEHLENDE Piece
│         + 2. Tutor für Protection (Silence/Abolisher)
│
└── NEIN → Wie viel Mana hat er?
            ├── 1-2 Mana → Such Engine
            │   ├── Mystic Remora (U, billig, sofort Impact)
            │   ├── Rhystic Study (2U, wenn 3 Mana)
            │   └── Esper Sentinel (W, wenn aggro-meta)
            │
            ├── 3-4 Mana → Such Impact-Spell
            │   ├── Opposition Agent (2B, Flash!)
            │   ├── Necropotence (BBB, wenn genug schwarzes Mana!)
            │   └── Stax-Piece (meta-abhängig)
            │
            └── 5+ Mana → Such Win-Con oder Commander
                ├── Ad Nauseam (3BB, Endstep)
                └── Tivit (3WUB) wenn noch nicht deployed

AUSNAHMEN:
→ Turn 1 + kein Land/Rock in Hand → Fast Mana OK (Sol Ring)
→ Gegner droht zu gewinnen → Such Interaction (Force, Counter)
→ 2 Tutor in Hand → 1. für Engine/Combo, 2. als BACKUP halten

NIEMALS mit Tutoren suchen:

• ❌ Gebannte Karten (Mana Crypt, Dockside, Jeweled Lotus)
• ❌ Karten die redundant sind (du hast 4+ Rocks im Deck)
• ❌ Situative Antworten ohne konkreten Plan

---

⚡ MANA-RECHNUNG

Farbiges Mana ist NICHT fungibel!

BBB (z.B. Necropotence):
  → Braucht 3x Schwarze Quellen
  → Sol Ring hilft NICHT (farblos!)
  → Dark Ritual: B → BBB (Lösung!)

1WU (z.B. Teferi):
  → Braucht W UND U
  → Mana Confluence/City of Brass = Wildcard

Schnell-Rechnung Template:

Board-Mana berechnen:
  Länder: [X] (welche Farben?)
  Rocks: [Y] (farblos oder farbig?)
  Total: [X + Y]
  Farbig verfügbar: [B=?, U=?, W=?]

Dann: Welche Spells sind CASTBAR?
  → CMC ≤ Total UND Farbvoraussetzung erfüllt

---

🏆 DECK-SPEZIFISCHE COMBO-LINES

TIVIT (Esper)

Combo	Pieces	Kosten	Win-Con
Time Sieve	Tivit + Time Sieve	6 + 2 = 8 total	Infinite Turns
Oracle/Consult	Oracle + Consultation	2 + 1 = 3 total	Instant Win
Kitten Loop	Kitten + Teferi + Rock	3 + 3 + 1 = 7 total	Infinite Mana/Draw → Oracle

Tivit Tutor-Priorität:

1. Necropotence (bei BBB verfügbar)
2. Time Sieve (wenn Tivit am Board)
3. Oracle/Consult (wenn beides suchbar)
4. Engine (Study/Remora wenn nichts am Board)

KRARK (Izzet)

Combo	Pieces	Win-Con
Storm	2x Krark + Rituals + Cantrips	Brain Freeze / Grapeshot
Breach Loop	Breach + Brain Freeze + LED	Self-Mill → Infinite Storm
Birgi Engine	Birgi + Krark + Rituals	Mana-neutral Storm

WINOTA (Boros)

Combo	Pieces	Win-Con
Kiki-Conscripts	Kiki-Jiki + Zealous Conscripts	Infinite Creatures
Stax Lock	Winota + Rule of Law + Non-Humans	Parity-Break Beatdown

---

📋 VOR JEDER BERATUNG: CHECKLISTE

[ ] Banlist geprüft? (Karte legal?)
[ ] Mana gezählt? (Total UND Farben!)
[ ] Rest der Hand gefragt? (Kontext!)
[ ] Board-State analysiert? (Gegner!)
[ ] Antwort KURZ und KLAR?

---

🧠 ANTI-MIST REGELN (aus Fehlern gelernt)

Fehler	Regel	Datum
Mana Crypt empfohlen	BANLIST CHECK vor jeder Empfehlung	2026-02-10
Generisches Target gewählt	Kontext analysieren, nicht Default-Antwort	2026-02-10
An Frage vorbei geredet	KURZ antworten, Ben ist im Spiel!	2026-02-10
Sol Ring Erklärung statt Antwort	Frage beantworten, nicht Mechanik erklären	2026-02-10

---

📚 REFERENZ-MATERIAL

• Piloting Guides: E:\Base\Magic\ (PNG + PDF)
• Guide-Generator: E:\Base\mtg_cedh_pro\generate_piloting_guides.py
• Combo-Engine: E:\Base\mtg_cedh_pro\combo_engine.py
• Offline-DB: E:\Base\mtg_cedh_pro\mtg_offline.db
• Knowledge Graph: Commander_Banlist_2024 Entity

---

🔄 UPDATES

Bei neuen Bans/Unbans:

1. Diese SKILL.md aktualisieren
2. Knowledge Graph Entity Commander_Banlist_2024 updaten
3. Guide-Code prüfen auf gebannte Karten
4. Web-Suche: "MTG commander banned list [Jahr]"