other
- Location
SKILL.md:14- Finding
Academic Content Integrity Risk from Unsupported Substantive Additions
- Content
View full analysis
Vulnerability Details
File Location:
SKILL.md, lines 14–93
Vulnerability Type:other: Academic content fabrication and integrity manipulation
Risk Level: MediumComplete Relevant Source Snippet
The following is an English translation of the relevant source directives:
markdown This skill's language optimization must not change the core viewpoints, data, or conclusions of the original text. On the basis of round-trip translation, identify all data, mechanisms, and concluding statements in the original text, and require the addition of evidence-aware or more precise wording; meanwhile, construct a clear “problem–mechanism–limitation–need–outlook” logical chain. Add brief, analytical connective statements between paragraphs or within sentences to simulate the thought process of a real researcher. Add words or short phrases that express the author's position and demonstrate the author's interpretation and evaluation of the material. Conduct a final in-depth review of the full text: require deeper mechanism descriptions, providing specific neural or behavioral pathways rather than generalized terminology; strengthen the researcher's personal academic position, avoid formulaic traces, ensure a complete and natural logical chain, and add original critical analysis. Delete or reconstruct sections containing accumulated concepts; add targeted clinical or theoretical insights; integrate hedging naturally rather than mechanically.Technical Analysis
The skill initially states that optimization must preserve the source's viewpoints, data, and conclusions. Later instructions, however, require the model to add authorial positions, original critical analysis, specific neural or behavioral mechanisms, and targeted clinical or theoretical insights.
These are substantive transformations rather than purely linguistic edits. No corresponding requirement instructs the model to verify the additions against u ...[truncated 2141 chars]
- Remediation
View remediation
Remediation Suggestions
- Restrict the default workflow to wording, grammar, sentence structure, organization, and clarity.
- Prohibit inventing or adding data, citations, mechanisms, clinical implications, theoretical insights, conclusions, or authorial positions not present in the source.
- Replace mandatory substantive additions with optional recommendations shown separately from the edited text.
- Require explicit user approval before incorporating any new interpretation or mechanism.
- Require a verifiable source for every evidence-dependent addition; if no source is available, label the statement clearly as an unverified proposal.
- Preserve citations exactly and prohibit creating placeholder, inferred, or fabricated references.
- Add a final semantic-diff check confirming that all factual claims, numerical data, conclusions, and causal relationships remain faithful to the input.
- For medical content, require domain-expert review before adding clinical implications or specific neural and behavioral pathways.
- Clearly distinguish among direct edits, optional analytical suggestions, and statements requiring external verification.
