Debate Learning Workflow

Run evidence-backed multi-agent debates (A/B/Opponent3/Judge) with 20-40 rounds, loophole analysis, and universal actionable lesson extraction.

Security Scan

The skill is instruction-only and its requirements and actions (running multi-agent debates and writing results to files on the user's Desktop) are consistent with its stated purpose.

Purpose & Capability

Name/description (structured multi-agent debates, lesson extraction) align with the SKILL.md rules and outputs. No unexpected credentials, binaries, or external services are requested.

Instruction Scope

Instructions are narrowly focused on running debate rounds, logging loopholes, judge decisions, and producing lesson artifacts. They explicitly write output files to ~/Desktop (topic, daily index, lessons). This is coherent with the skill's purpose but means the agent will create/modify files in the user's home directory; the SKILL.md does not instruct reading unrelated system files or environment variables.

Install Mechanism

No install spec and no code files are present (instruction-only). This minimizes risk because nothing is downloaded or installed on disk by the skill itself.

Credentials

No environment variables, credentials, or config paths are required. The declared requirements are proportional to the described functionality.

Persistence & Privilege

always is false and there is no request to modify other skills or system-wide agent settings. The skill will write its own output files but requests no elevated or persistent platform privileges.

Assessment

This skill is coherent with its description: it runs structured debates and writes files to ~/Desktop (topic files, daily index, lessons). Before installing or invoking it, consider: 1) local file writes — review or redirect the output paths if you don't want files on your Desktop; 2) potential volume — 20–40 rounds per topic can produce large notebooks of content; 3) evidence sourcing — the skill requires Claim+Evidence+Source in openings, so an agent using web searches could fetch or quote external sources (the SKILL.md does not explicitly require network access, but evidence collection may cause the agent to access the web); 4) review outputs for sensitive content before sharing. No credentials or installs are requested, and nothing in the instructions appears to attempt data exfiltration or access to unrelated system configuration.

Use this skill to run structured, high-rigor debates that produce transferable learning.

Core Rules

• Minimum 20 rounds per topic.
• Judge-gated continuation if critical loopholes remain.
• Hard stop at 40 rounds.
• Openings must include Claim + Evidence + Source.
• Unsupported openings are invalid and must be revised.
• Every round logs:
  • loophole found
  • why loophole exists
  • concrete fix for next round

Roles

• Debater A
• Debater B
• Opponent3 (alternative/challenger model)
• Judge (evidence quality + unresolved uncertainty)

Output Files

• Topic file: ~/Desktop/debate/YYYY-MM-DD-topic.md
• Daily index: ~/Desktop/debate/YYYY-MM-DD-index.md
• Lessons append target: ~/Desktop/lessons.md

Universalization Quality Gate

Every generalized lesson must include:

1. Trigger condition
2. Loophole/failure pattern
3. Root cause
4. Corrective action
5. Measurable metric/threshold
6. Boundary conditions
7. Transfer examples in at least 2 other fields

If any field is missing, lesson is INVALID and must be rewritten.