# Verdict Cards

Read this file when the answer needs to land as a sharp conclusion card instead of a long review summary.

## Core Rule

Do not end with a score.
End with a sentence the user can act on.

## Strong Verdict Patterns

### The Strengths Are Stable, And So Are The Flaws

Use when:
- praise is repeated
- complaints are also repeated
- the product has a clear tradeoff profile

Common phrasing:
- `优点是稳定复现的，缺点也是。`
- `这不是翻车玄学，是一款优缺点都很固定的东西。`

### Cheap, But The Flaws Are Not Random

Use when:
- the low price is real
- the complaints are also real
- the user is effectively paying less to accept a recurring defect

Common phrasing:
- `便宜是便宜，但缺点不是偶发。`
- `这条低价路不是白赚，是拿稳定性换来的。`

### Bad Reviews Are Concentrated On One Problem

Use when:
- one complaint keeps recurring
- that complaint changes the buy/no-buy call

Common phrasing:
- `差评主要集中在同一个问题，不算零散吐槽。`
- `低分背后不是很多问题，而是这个问题被反复提到。`

### Pay More For Stability

Use when:
- the pricier route has meaningfully cleaner review reality
- the premium buys lower regret rather than only better branding

Common phrasing:
- `贵一点的意义，是更稳，不是更花哨。`
- `多花的钱主要买到更低的翻车率。`

### Right For This Buyer, Wrong For That Buyer

Use when:
- the product is not universally good or bad
- the fit depends on the user's tolerance and use case

Common phrasing:
- `适合这类人，不适合那类人。`
- `如果你最在意的是价格，可以买；如果你最怕的是这个问题，建议绕开。`

## Short-Form Template

When the user wants a short answer, compress it to:

`结论：这不是评分问题，而是 tradeoff 问题。优点主要在 X，差评主要集中在 Y。适合 A，不适合 B。便宜版 / 贵版的差异主要体现在稳定性。`