PM Requirement Review Simulator · Requirement Review

__requirement_name__ · PM Requirement Review Report

__one_line_summary__

__review_mode__ __requirement_type__ __industry__ __omitted_dim__ N/A __decision_verdict__

__generated_at__

__grade__

__total_score__ / 100

__grade__ · __decision_verdict__
__requirement_type__ · __weight_description__

Five-Dimension Radar

Logic Coherence

__dim0_score__

Tech Feasibility

__dim1_score__

Ops Value

__dim2_score__

Exec Alignment

__dim3_score__

Compliance

__dim4_score__

☠

Fatal Flaw

__fatal_flaw__

🛡

Lifeline

__lifeline__

🚦 Decision Gates

Gate	Status	Note
Value Gate	__vg_status__	__vg_note__
Risk Gate	__rg_status__	__rg_note__
Resource Gate	__sg_status__	__sg_note__
Strategy Gate	__tg_status__	__tg_note__

📐 A/B/C Plans

Plan	Scope	Timeline	Risk
A Full	__a_scope__	__a_time__	__a_risk__
B Recommended	__b_scope__	__b_time__	__b_risk__
C MVP	__c_scope__	__c_time__	__c_risk__

Recommended: __recommend__ · Checkpoint: __checkpoint__

🎭 Five-Role Challenge Board

Challenge linkage strategy: __challenge_strategy__

🛠 Tech Lead · Deliverability

#	Challenge	Level	Real Concern
1	__tech_q1__	__tech_lvl1__	__tech_c1__

📈 Operations Director · Growth Viability

#	Challenge	Level	Real Concern
1	__ops_q1__	__ops_lvl1__	__ops_c1__

🎨 Design Lead · Experience Quality

#	Challenge	Level	Real Concern
1	__ux_q1__	__ux_lvl1__	__ux_c1__

👔 Exec / Decision-Maker · Strategic Fit

#	Challenge	Level	Real Concern
1	__exec_q1__	__exec_lvl1__	__exec_c1__

⚖ Legal Advisor · Compliance & Risk

#	Challenge	Level	Real Concern
1	__legal_q1__	__legal_lvl1__	__legal_c1__

✨ Killer Replies TOP 3

The 3 hardest questions from all challenges — Normal Reply vs. Killer Reply.

Q: __kr1_q__

Normal Reply

__kr1_normal__

🌟 Killer Reply

__kr1_killer__

💡 Technique

__kr1_tip__

Q: __kr2_q__

Normal Reply

__kr2_normal__

🌟 Killer Reply

__kr2_killer__

💡 Technique

__kr2_tip__

Q: __kr3_q__

Normal Reply

__kr3_normal__

🌟 Killer Reply

__kr3_killer__

💡 Technique

__kr3_tip__

🤝 Cross-Team Collaboration

Task	Responsible (R)	Accountable (A)	Consulted (C)	Informed (I)	Deadline
__raci_1_task__	__raci_1_r__	__raci_1_a__	__raci_1_c__	__raci_1_i__	__raci_1_dl__
__raci_2_task__	__raci_2_r__	__raci_2_a__	__raci_2_c__	__raci_2_i__	__raci_2_dl__

⚡ Conflict Resolution

Type	Description	Impact	Resolution
__cf_1_type__	__cf_1_desc__	__cf_1_impact__	__cf_1_fix__
__cf_2_type__	__cf_2_desc__	__cf_2_impact__	__cf_2_fix__

📝 Review Meeting Script

🎯 Opening (3 min)

__script_open__

🔥 Core Argument (10 min)

__script_core__

⚠ Risk Mitigation (5 min)

__script_risk__

✅ Plan Selection

__script_plan__

🎤 Closing (5 min)

__script_close__

🔧 Optimization Suggestions

Priority	Point	Scope	Fix Cost	Solution
P0	__opt_1_point__	__opt_1_scope__	__opt_1_cost__	__opt_1_fix__
P1	__opt_2_point__	__opt_2_scope__	__opt_2_cost__	__opt_2_fix__
P2	__opt_3_point__	__opt_3_scope__	__opt_3_cost__	__opt_3_fix__

📋 Action Checklist

__owner__ completes __deliverable__ by __deadline__ · Checkpoint: __checkpoint__

⚠ Disclaimer

AI-Generated — This report is produced by PM Requirement Review Simulator (AI). It does not constitute professional advice or legal opinion.
Accuracy — Scores and challenges are based solely on user-provided inputs. Items marked "Inferred" are estimated and may affect scoring precision.
Compliance — Compliance and legal references are indicative only and do not replace licensed professional counsel.
Decision — Go / Conditional Go / No Go ratings are advisory only. Final decisions rest with the user.

PM Requirement Review Simulator · __generated_at__ · __review_mode__ · Survival Score __total_score__ / 100