{
  "schema_version": "1.2",
  "paper_id": "<paper_id>",
  "research_equation": {
    "old_success_or_paradigm": "<A(P)>",
    "broken_assumption": "<C and not-C>",
    "hard_setting_or_constraint": "<T>",
    "borrowed_tool_or_method_family": "<M>",
    "ideal_unavailable_mechanism": "<Y>",
    "surrogate_mechanism": "<Z>",
    "compact_formula": "A(P) ∩ ¬C ∩ T ∩ M => Z≈Y",
    "claim_ids": []
  },
  "tri_pass_notes": {
    "pass_1_five_c": {
      "category": "<paper category>",
      "context": "<field context and ancestor methods>",
      "correctness": "<initial assumption and evidence plausibility>",
      "contributions": "<claimed contributions>",
      "clarity": "<argument clarity>",
      "direction_promise": "<hidden assumption or research trigger noticed in triage>"
    },
    "pass_2_chain": "<problem -> assumption -> module -> formula -> figure/table -> experiment -> claim reconstruction>",
    "pass_3_virtual_reimplementation": "<assumptions, missing details, special cases, dropped-assumption failures>"
  },
  "direction_reconstruction": {
    "likely_starting_dissatisfaction": "<plausible pain point>",
    "tempting_transfer": "<nearby method that almost transfers>",
    "blocking_constraint": "<why direct transfer fails>",
    "conceptual_replacement": "<what the paper uses instead>",
    "interpretation_type": "<evidence-backed interpretation | plausible inference | speculation>",
    "claim_ids": []
  },
  "challenge_to_module_map": [
    {
      "challenge": "<challenge>",
      "failure_mode": "<failure mode>",
      "design_principle": "<design principle>",
      "module": "<module>",
      "evidence": "<claim ids or evidence notes>",
      "claim_ids": []
    }
  ],
  "module_hidden_assumptions": [
    {
      "module": "<module>",
      "failure_fixed": "<failure>",
      "ideal_unavailable_solution": "<ideal solution>",
      "available_proxy": "<proxy>",
      "design_choice": "<choice>",
      "hidden_assumption": "<assumption>",
      "risk_if_assumption_fails": "<risk>",
      "future_research_point": "<research seed>",
      "claim_ids": []
    }
  ],
  "citation_logic": [
    {
      "citation_cluster": "<cluster>",
      "narrative_function": "<field anchor | limitation evidence | method ancestor | neighboring inspiration | baseline pressure | protocol justification | contrast boundary>",
      "assumption_inherited": "<assumption>",
      "how_paper_modifies_it": "<modification>",
      "claim_ids": []
    }
  ],
  "experiments_as_story_evidence": [
    {
      "experiment_block": "<experiment>",
      "claim": "<supported claim>",
      "counterfactual": "<alternative explanation ruled out>",
      "metric": "<metric>",
      "stress_condition": "<hard setting tested>",
      "alignment_judgment": "<strong | partial | weak>",
      "claim_ids": []
    }
  ],
  "reviewer_lens_summary": {
    "novelty": "<audit>",
    "significance": "<audit>",
    "soundness": "<audit>",
    "methodology_rigor": "<audit>",
    "reproducibility": "<audit>",
    "limitations_honesty": "<audit>",
    "actionable_objections": []
  },
  "story_pattern": {
    "pattern_name": "<replacement story | closed loop | two-axis empty cell | other>",
    "compact_formula": "<pattern formula>",
    "reusable_lesson": "<lesson>",
    "claim_ids": []
  },
  "future_directions": [
    {
      "direction": "<direction>",
      "seed_type": "<seed type>",
      "trigger": "<hidden assumption, proxy mismatch, evidence gap, successor gap, reviewer objection, or negative result>",
      "minimum_viable_experiment": "<small test>",
      "killer_objection": "<objection>",
      "killer_result": "<decisive result>",
      "direction_seed_id": "<D1>",
      "claim_ids": []
    }
  ],
  "top_direction_seed_ids": ["D1"],
  "direction_board_path": "direction_board.json"
}